Donald Trump wants to enjoy a long weekend of golfing. Good luck with that.
The U.S. president lands in Scotland, his mother’s birthplace, on Friday for the
first time since his return to the White House. On the itinerary is time at his
Turnberry and Aberdeen golf resorts, plus meetings with U.K. Prime Minister Keir
Starmer and Scottish First Minister John Swinney.
But with colorful protests expected, Trump’s trip has prompted a security
operation as big as Queen Elizabeth’s funeral in 2022. Up to 6,000 officers will
shield the most powerful man in the world from what are expected to be
significant demonstrations. The Scottish Police Federation has already queried
whether adequate resources are in place to manage such a huge operation.
So what do those closest to the action think about the circus coming to town?
POLITICO grilled seven plugged-in Scottish politicians of all stripes on the
flying visit — and asked where Trump should go if he does manage to venture away
from the golf course.
ELAINE STEWART, LABOUR MP FOR AYR, CARRICK & CUMNOCK
Elaine Stewart has only been the Labour MP whose patch covers Trump Turnberry
for just over a year — but she isn’t daunted by the president’s arrival.
“He’s been here before,” Stewart says. “That same spectacle happened when he was
president the first time.”
Despite concerns around policing, Stewart — who recalls the last presidential
Trump trip to Scotland — says she’s confident this visit will go off without a
security hitch. “There was security on the beaches and the roads and there were
loads of police everywhere,” she says. “Loads of people … watched because it’s
something that they thought they would never see again,” Stewart mused. “But
here we are.”
Stewart has been meeting farmers in her local constituency — who say they
benefit directly from Trump’s presence. “[The resort] sources all his meat and
his seafood and vegetables locally,” she says. The U.S. president loves a grand
gesture and a prime bit of real estate — so Stewart recommends a trip to the
clifftop Culzean Castle just a few miles from Turnberry. Dating back centuries,
the stately home has a suite gifted to former U.S. President Dwight Eisenhower
for his military leadership during the Second World War as supreme commander of
the Allied Expeditionary Force in Europe.
ALEC CLARK, INDEPENDENT DEPUTY LEADER OF SOUTH AYRSHIRE COUNCIL
Trump’s presence will generate global attention — but Alec Clark will have to
deal with the local reaction long after the president has jetted back to
America. The independent deputy leader of South Ayrshire Council, whose ward
includes Trump Turnberry, is in a sunny mood about the trip, praising the funds
that Trump’s company has plowed into the tiny rural village.
“The actual investment that goes into Turnberry year after year, week after
week, day after day, is tremendous,” Clark says, lauding the more than 400
people employed “in a rural area where every job is like gold dust.”
The estate unsurprisingly became a huge attraction after Trump entered politics,
and Clark has noticed that “tourists are stopping there to take photographs of
the hotel.” He ascribes Trump’s “sympathetic stance” toward Scotland to his
mother’s Scottish roots.
On the itinerary is time at his Turnberry and Aberdeen golf resorts. | Robert
Perry/EPA
As police prepare for protests, Clark defends such dissent as “one of the things
you’ve got to handle” in a democracy. “It’s only courteous to listen, because
people can protest … but the only way to make a difference is to discuss,” he
reflects.
If Trump does have some time away from the golf buggy, Clark reckons he should
pop along to the Robert Burns museum in Alloway, a suburb north of Turnberry, to
learn more about the poet and view some original manuscripts. “Burns is
history,” Clark says. “Burns is the National Bard of Scotland. He’s known all
over the world.”
BRIAN WHITTLE, TORY SCOTTISH PARLIAMENT MEMBER (MSP) FOR SOUTH SCOTLAND
Brian Whittle is no stranger to presidential big beasts rolling into town. Prior
to entering the Scottish Parliament to represent South Scotland — which includes
Turnberry — the Conservative MSP ran an event management company that organized
a visit to Glasgow by Bill Clinton.
When U.S. presidents come to Scotland, they don’t travel lightly.
Clinton’s trip in the mid-2000s after leaving the White House involved three
months of preparation, Whittle said, including many meetings with the U.S.
Secret Service and British spooks in MI5 and MI6.
“If that’s the level of security required for a former president of the United
States, a current president, especially one with Donald Trump’s current
reputation … would be even greater, much greater than what I had to deal with,”
he says.
Given that Trump’s visit — billed as a private trip — is a tad spontaneous,
Whittle isn’t surprised there’s been a “bit of scrambling around to make sure
all the protocols are in place.”
“No matter where he goes, there’ll be protests,” the Tory MSP says. “That’s part
of the deal, that’s part of the job.”
But he urges Scots not to get too excited. “On one level, this story is about:
Somebody owns a bit of property and is coming to see a property.”
Whittle says Turnberry is a “massive asset” that encourages global visitors. “If
you go down there, it’s always busy as a venue,” he adds.
WENDY CHAMBERLAIN, LIB DEM MP FOR NORTH EAST FIFE
As a former cop, the Liberal Democrat MP for North East Fife, Wendy Chamberlain,
is thinking about the “day-to-day” impact on policing of the Trump team rolling
into town. “These are huge logistical challenges for police forces,” she says.
“One of the challenges of it being private is there seems to be a lack of
knowledge about what’s actually happening.”
Keir Starmer’s Westminster administration has been at pains to cosy up to Donald
Trump. | Pool Photo by Ludovic Marin via EPA
Chamberlain is the chief enforcer of House of Commons discipline for the
centrist Liberal Democrats, who have built a brand around calling out Trump.
“There always has been quite an active protest movement, sometimes with a good
deal of humor as well, which is very Scottish,” Chamberlain says.
But she understands why Starmer and Swinney — both from center-left parties —
would meet with the right-wing Republican firebrand. “You have to look past the
individual that’s in the role of the president of the United States — and look
at the role itself,” she says.
MERCEDES VILLALBA, LABOUR MSP FOR NORTH EAST SCOTLAND
Starmer’s Westminster administration has been at pains to cosy up to Trump. Not
everyone in his party is happy.
Mercedes Villalba, a Labour MSP for North East Scotland, which covers Trump’s
Aberdeen estate, is a fierce critic of the U.S. president’s foreign policy —
especially in the Middle East.
Her constituents will show support for “the Palestinian people and their right
to self-determination,” she says, with the Palestinian flag flying above
Dundee’s City Chambers, a place twinned with Nablus in the Occupied West Bank
since 1980.
“Our region’s rich history of solidarity at home and abroad is alien to Donald
Trump,” Villalba said. To her, Trump is a “convicted felon who has pledged to
turn Gaza into the ‘Riviera of the Middle East’ and continues to send weapons to
a state credibly accused of genocide.”
Villalba has no doubt her constituents “will make their opposition to the U.S.
president’s visit abundantly clear,” and hopes Swinney demonstrates “the same
commitment to peace and justice” during his own expected meeting with the U.S.
president.
TESS WHITE, CONSERVATIVE MSP FOR NORTH EAST SCOTLAND
Northeastern Scotland sits on vast quantities of gas and oil — but the British
government is wary about the climate impacts of getting stuck in.
Having worked in the energy sector for three decades, Tess White, a Tory MSP for
the region, hopes the president’s trip will spark “widespread recognition” of
the dangers of switching to renewables too quickly.
Trump has long complained about Scotland’s wind turbines. White said she hopes
that “President Trump will do in two days what the SNP have just failed to do in
over a decade,” aiming a shot at Scotland’s ruling Scottish National Party. She
reckons Trump should visit the government-run renewables investment body GB
Energy in Aberdeen — to see for himself that it’s “really not a serious vehicle
for strengthening and improving our oil and gas industry.”
White also blames “very, very” stretched policing around the visit on the SNP.
“Police officers are under immense strain with millions of hours in overtime
being notched up,” she warns.
When in town, White recommends Trump try some Angus beef (“the best in the
world”) and additive-free locally grown fruit.
Northeastern Scotland sits on vast quantities of gas and oil — but the British
government is wary about the climate impacts of getting stuck in. | Robert
Perry/EPA
TORCUIL CRICHTON, LABOUR MP FOR NA H-EILEANAN AN IAR
Torcuil Crichton has served as Labour MP for Na h-Eileanan an Iar since last
July. The Western Isles include Lewis, where Trump’s mother Mary Anne MacLeod
was born in 1912.
“People in Lewis are very proud of Mary Anne MacLeod and that entire emigration
generation of islanders who left in their thousands during the hungry 1920s and
made America great,” Crichton said.
“Mr Trump is a son of Lewis,” he added. “While oceans separate our politics, any
island exile is embraced on their return.
“Every prodigal son is welcomed home.”