BERLIN — German prosecutors announced Thursday the arrest of a Ukrainian
national suspected of helping coordinate the 2022 sabotage of the Nord Stream
gas pipelines.
The federal prosecutor general said Italian police detained Serhii K. overnight
in Rimini using a European arrest warrant. He is accused of being one of the
organizers of an operation that placed explosives on the Nord Stream 1 and 2
pipelines near the Danish island of Bornholm in September 2022.
The blasts caused massive gas leaks and severely damaged both pipelines, cutting
a crucial energy link between Russia and Europe.
Investigators believe the group used a yacht rented from the German port of
Rostock under false identities to transport explosives to the site. Traces of
the military-grade explosive octogen were later discovered on board.
According to German authorities, Serhii K. was “urgently suspected” of
coordinating the attack alongside others. He faces charges of causing an
explosion, committing anti-constitutional sabotage, and destroying
infrastructure.
The arrest marks a breakthrough in a complex investigation that has stretched
across several countries. Sweden and Denmark closed their probes without naming
suspects earlier this year, while Germany pressed ahead with its case, focusing
on a small team of divers and support staff thought to have carried out the
mission. Reports from Western officials have pointed to possible links with
Ukrainian networks, though Kyiv has consistently denied any involvement.
The suspect will be transferred to Germany to face a federal judge in Karlsruhe.
Tag - Nord Stream 1
RUSSIAN OIL OR MASS LAYOFFS: A GERMAN TOWN’S CONUNDRUM
In Schwedt, life flows through an oil refinery. If it doesn’t get help — or
restart Russian imports — people worry their jobs will be gone.
By VICTOR JACK, JOHANNA SAHLBERG
and BEN LEFEBVRE in Schwedt, Germany
Chimneys of the PCK refinery and other companies in the Schwedt industrial park.
| Wolfram Steinberg/picture alliance via Getty Images
Annekathrin Hoppe’s town, her community, the people she oversees as mayor, are
losing their lifeline. Many now fear their jobs are next.
They say a bit of Russian oil could change that.
In Schwedt, life flows through a partly Russian-owned oil refinery. The
sprawling plant provides a living for around a fifth of the city’s 30,000
residents. Hoppe once worked there before becoming mayor. It’s been the
community’s beating heart for six decades.
“The refinery is the reason the town exists,” Hoppe said, sitting in a spartan
second-floor office overlooking the neat rows of the pale Plattenbau apartment
blocks that once dominated Soviet-controlled East Germany.
Yet like those apartment blocks, the refinery may soon become a relic of the
past. In late 2022, the plant lost its steady Russian energy diet when the aptly
named Druzhba (Friendship) pipeline abruptly dried up due to sanctions. Moscow’s
oil was no longer welcome after Russia invaded Ukraine.
The plant has yet to recover. And Hoppe is now appealing to Berlin for action —
even if it means bringing back Russian oil.
After the war broke out, Berlin put the refinery under a temporary trusteeship,
seizing Russian firm Rosneft’s majority stake. But Rosneft still owns its
shares. | Fabian Sommer/picture alliance via Getty Images
“It is so difficult for people and for all of us here in Schwedt to accept this
new economic reality,” said the center-left politician. “Of course we don’t
accept the war,” she added, but “traditionally we have always had good relations
with Russia,” echoing a sentiment felt across eastern Germany.
Her pleas showcase Europe’s growing conundrum. All over the continent, a
bubbling chorus of business leaders and politicians is urging governments to
revisit their hard-line stances on Moscow as ceasefire talk hangs in the air and
economic anxiety mounts.
Standing in the way are a raft of legal and political hurdles. Officials in
Berlin, Brussels and elsewhere are putting up walls, even pushing new plans to
end the bloc’s reliance on Moscow for good. But that reserve won’t necessarily
hold if political sentiment shifts, the fighting ceases, and struggling
industries start demanding access to cheaper Russian energy.
For the first time in years, “the potential for restarting or increasing Russian
supplies again seems like a possibility,” said Jonathan Stern, a Russia
specialist and founder of the gas program at the Oxford Institute for Energy
Studies, a research organization that receives money from fossil fuel firms and
governments.
BACKWARD FLOW
Shortly after Vladimir Putin’s troops marched toward Kyiv, the EU slapped
sanctions on Moscow’s key economic lifeline, fossil fuels.
Three years later, the continent has nearly unwound its own long-held reliance
on Russian energy. Gas pipeline imports are down by two-thirds, and oil and coal
shipments by sea are banned.
Enter Donald Trump.
The returning president’s vow to end the fighting has given oxygen to EU voices
arguing that a ceasefire could presage a return to Russian energy. Europe’s
economic stagnation, and gas and power prices still at double prewar levels, are
adding still more fuel to that fire.
The bloc’s far-right forces, from Austria’s Freedom Party to Bulgaria’s Revival,
have long called for restarting supplies from Moscow. But now mainstream
politicians, including Italy’s energy minister and officials from Germany’s
ruling center-right, are also refusing to rule it out. Even Ukraine’s sanctions
envoy said it would be “stupid” not to eventually restart imports.
Europe’s energy sector is keen, too. In France alone, energy firms TotalEnergies
and Engie have said Europe could eventually up Russian gas buys by 40 percent.
“There are definitely companies out there who would take it,” said one gas
trader, granted anonymity to discuss the politically charged topic. It has
become “common sense that if there is peace, then gas will come.”
In Germany — the nucleus of Europe’s economic slump — the debate is
crescendoing. Politicians from both the ruling Social Democrats and Christian
Democrats have debated reviving the Russia-to-Germany Nord Stream pipelines,
which were destroyed in 2022, although Friedrich Merz is now pushing to sanction
the subsea links.
Protesters, including workers from the nearby PCK oil refinery, demand an end to
the embargo of Russian oil imports in 2022. | Christian Ender/Getty Images
A spokesperson for Germany’s economy ministry said the country had “set itself
the goal of becoming independent of Russian oil as quickly as possible — and has
successfully achieved this.”
But “pressure will definitely grow,” said Stefan Meister of the German Council
on Foreign Relations, as “more voices from different companies, but also from
politicians on the local level … demand returning to cheap Russian oil and gas.”
Secluded and nestled between a dense thicket of trees on the edge of town, the
Schwedt refinery encapsulates that shift.
Responsible for supplying over 90 percent of Berlin’s oil, its giant airport and
a network of businesses from paper mills to pipeline processors, the facility is
facing a battery of difficulties. With its Russian imports gone, the site now
operates at 80 percent capacity and receives oil from Germany’s Rostock
pipeline, Poland’s Gdańsk port and Kazakhstan via Druzhba.
That leaves the refinery “in the red,” given the site’s fixed running costs,
according to Danny Ruthenberg, who heads the facility’s works council. Last
month, the government extended an employment guarantee at the facility until the
end of the year, giving its workers temporary respite. But within the next two
years, up to 1,000 jobs will be at risk, Ruthenberg claimed.
Russian energy could prevent that. Plus, Ruthenberg said, it “doesn’t require
any [new] investment.”
Danny Ruthenberg, the head of the refinery’s works council, worries about
looming job cuts at the facility. | Victor Jack/POLITICO
“When peace is there again, then you have to trade with Russia,” he added.
The PCK consortium, which owns the refinery, didn’t respond to a request for
comment from POLITICO.
POLITICS OVER LAW
But bringing Moscow back into the fold won’t be easy — even if the barriers
remain more political than legal.
For Schwedt, plugging the tangled metallic mesh of pipelines, distillation units
and towering chimneys back into Moscow’s oil pump first means dealing with its
convoluted legal structure.
After the war broke out, Berlin put the refinery under a temporary trusteeship,
seizing Russian firm Rosneft’s majority stake. But Rosneft still owns its
shares.
Any attempt to restart supplies from Moscow would therefore require the EU to
lift its oil embargo, Poland to accept Russian crude passing through its
pipeline network and Germany to force Rosneft to sell its shares to banks and
suppliers on board, said Tibor Fedke, a senior energy lawyer at the Noerr law
firm.
A protester in Schwedt wears a hard hat with the writing “PCK” and an image of
Russian President Vladimir Putin, in 2022. | Omer Messinger/Getty Images
After that, signing new legal contracts would be “in theory very, very easy,” he
said. While the new owner would still have to convince other shareholders and
suppliers that they would not be hurt by future sanctions, it’s largely “a
political matter,” Fedke added.
The story is similar for Nord Stream. European backers of the pipelines, which
lie shattered deep under the Baltic Sea, have demanded that Russia’s Gazprom
iron out its legal disputes before revival talk seriously begins. Germany’s
regulator must also approve the flow of Moscow’s gas.
“Assuming there’s political will,” said Stern, the gas expert, that signoff can
be done overnight, he said. The physical fix could be done in “months,” he
added.
Ukraine is the other potential postwar path for Russian gas to reenter the EU,
Stern said. Pipelines criss-crossing Ukraine once carried half of Moscow’s
exports to Europe. But those flows ended in January after Kyiv let a transit
deal with Moscow expire.
“I think if we saw a meaningful ceasefire, we might see traders from all over
asking Gazprom: ‘Will you sell us gas on the Ukrainian border … where we’ve got
people who’ll buy it?’” he said.
The crude oil processing control center on the premises of PCK. | Patrick
Pleul/picture alliance via Getty Images
Elsewhere, countries like the Czech Republic have upgraded oil pipeline
infrastructure to ensure their refineries are supplied with non-Russian fuels.
But that doesn’t lock them into those alternatives.
“Logistically, it wouldn’t be an issue at all,” said Homayoun Falakshahi, head
of crude analysis at Kpler, a commodities firm that tracks global oil shipping.
“It would be very, very easy to switch back to Russian crude” — whether it
arrives by ship or pipeline.
CREAKING CENTER
So far, mainstream politicians have stayed resolute on ending Russian imports.
Germany’s Merz in May vowed to ensure “that Nord Stream 2 cannot be put back
into operation,” even backing fresh EU sanctions on the pipelines for good
measure.
The EU, too, is steaming ahead with plans to quit Russian supplies.
Brussels last month proposed legislation to fully phase out Moscow’s gas imports
by 2027.
“It’s quite clear that we have already learned the lesson that dependency on
energy imports from Russia is not without a price,” Lithuanian Energy Minister
Žygimantas Vaičiūnas told POLITICO. “So sooner or later, we are paying the price
for that.”
“We’re not going back,” echoed one EU official, speaking anonymously to discuss
the sensitive subject. Even a ceasefire in Ukraine is not equivalent to a
“long-term peace,” the official added.
Patrick Pleul/picture alliance via Getty Images
But achieving that is far from a given. There’s legal uncertainty about
Brussels’ gas-quitting legislation, while countries such as Austria, Slovakia
and Hungary want to leave the door open for Russian imports. At the same time,
Budapest and Bratislava are constantly threatening to tank the EU’s Russia
sanctions in retaliation.
Meanwhile, the Kremlin has hollowed out a Western price cap on Russian oil,
selling its oil via an army of creaky tankers with opaque ownership.
Additionally, an EU offer in 2022 to spend €2 billion on helping plants pivot
away from Russian energy has come to little, at least in the bloc’s most heavily
dependent countries of Slovakia and Hungary.
That missing money is being felt in Schwedt. The German government once pledged
€400 million to upgrade Germany’s Rostock oil pipeline and help Schwedt replace
its Russian supplies. But Brussels never approved the new cash.
“We’re disappointed,” said Ruthenberg, the refinery’s works council chief. “The
chancellor promised money that never came.”
Hoppe, the mayor, stressed she would rather see the refinery shun Russian oil —
but the frozen funding might leave the city with little choice but to consider
Moscow. “The new federal government and the EU must act together to start on the
developments they promised,” she said.
Schwedt’s mayor, Annekathrin Hoppe, and the chairman of the municipal council,
Hans-Joachim Höppner, want the new German government to secure previously
promised funds for the refinery. | Victor Jack/POLITICO
According to one senior German lawmaker, decisions about the refinery’s future
are “still pending” in Berlin. “Ultimately, it is important that there are
sustainable prospects for the site that will also secure jobs,” the lawmaker
said, granted anonymity to discuss the process.
A European Commission spokesperson said that the EU executive was “in close and
constructive contact with the German authorities” on the funding, while
declining to give further details. The German economy ministry spokesperson said
that sales talks with Rosneft were “ongoing,” while discussions with Brussels
over cash funding were still “underway.”
“Ensuring security of supply remains the top priority” regarding the refinery,
the economy ministry spokesperson added.
In the meantime, political pressure is starting to boil. Flanked by two
Russia-friendly parties — the vociferous Alliance Sahra Wagenknecht on the left
and an ascendant far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) on the right — German
centrist regional government leaders from Brandenburg to Saxony to Thuringia are
cautiously backing a Russia return, said Meister, the political scientist.
In the country’s east, especially, “you just have a very Russia-friendly
society,” he said. “You cannot [pursue] a fully-fledged policy against this
mood.”
Many East Germans still see themselves as second-class citizens compared with
the country’s more historically affluent West, according to recent polling,
while Germans with Russian ethnic roots are almost twice as likely to support
the AfD as their peers.
A pensioner with a walker, in Schwedt. | Bildagentur-online/Schoening/Universal
Images Group via Getty Images
Behind closed doors, opponents fear a German volte-face could spark a domino
effect. Three EU diplomats fretted that Italy, Austria, Bulgaria and the Czech
Republic are all at risk of following suit on Russia if Germany caves.
A Bulgarian official said the country remains “fully aligned” with the EU’s
strategy to quit Russian energy. “Austria does not comment on such
speculations,” said a spokesperson for the country’s energy ministry.
The Czech and Italian permanent representations in Brussels didn’t respond to a
request for comment from POLITICO.
THE TRUMP CARD
More powerful than those internal pressures is an external force: Trump.
Despite his campaign pledge to end the bloodshed in Ukraine in “24 hours,” the
U.S. president has struggled to make progress on a ceasefire. The former reality
show star has wavered on further sanctions against Moscow, while heaping praise
on the Russian leader and persistently backing closer economic ties with the
Kremlin.
“Russia wants to do largescale TRADE with the United States when this
catastrophic ‘bloodbath’ is over, and I agree,” Trump wrote after a two-hour
call with Putin in May.
U.S. President Donald Trump nd German Chancellor Friedrich Merz meet at the Oval
Office. | Pool photo by Chris Kleponis via Getty Images
That debate is also firing up his administration. While White House special
envoy Steve Witkoff wants to lift energy sanctions on Russia, according to two
people familiar with the matter, Interior Secretary Doug Burgum would rather
displace Moscow to make room for more U.S. imports.
In any case, Europe’s energy sector is at the heart of that potential
cooperation. Moscow is in talks with Washington over restarting Nord Stream,
backed by U.S. investors.
That’s sparking anxiety in Brussels. Trump and Putin “want to divide the
European energy market and create [separate] spheres of influence,” said a
second EU official, also granted anonymity.
Schwedt, too, could be swept into a U.S.-Russia peace deal. American investors
are reportedly exploring buying up Rosneft’s shares in the refinery, according
to German investigative outlet Correctiv. That would give U.S. firms a majority
share in the facility.
“In an alternate universe in which Russia makes peace with the West and Ukraine
specifically, Schwedt would look a lot more appealing,” said Clayton Seigle, an
energy analyst at the Washington-based Center for Strategic and International
Studies think tank.
For locals, that solution is as good as any. “Americans are ultimately our
friends,” said Ruthenberg, the refinery’s works council leader. If the U.S.
“wants to invest here … we will no longer be at a standstill.”
That does, of course, mean a Trump-branded partnership.
But “Trump is for a limited time,” Hoppe quipped with a chuckle. “We hope.”