The European Union can continue to count nuclear power, and in some cases fossil
gas, as “environmentally sustainable,” after the EU’s top court ruled the
European Commission was not breaching its obligations to tackle climate change.
The General Court on Wednesday found against a complaint from Austria, which
sought to overturn the decision to include the two energy sources in the EU’s
taxonomy regulation, which determines which investments can be considered as
green.
The General Court, part of the Court of Justice of the European Union, said in
its judgment the Commission “was entitled to take the view that nuclear energy
generation has near to zero greenhouse gas emissions and that there are
currently no technologically and economically feasible low-carbon alternatives
at a sufficient scale.”
The court added it “endorses the view that economic activities in the nuclear
energy and fossil gas sectors can, under certain conditions, contribute
substantially to climate change mitigation and climate change adaptation.”
The case was brought by Vienna in 2022, arguing that the inclusion of nuclear
power and fossil gas breached EU law and that the Commission had neglected to
carry out an impact assessment or public consultation and bypassed normal
legislative processes.
Leonore Gewessler, who was then Austria’s climate and energy minister and now
leads the opposition Green Party, launched the legal action after the list of
green investments was published almost three years ago.
“What I oppose with all my might is the attempt to greenwash nuclear power and
gas via the backdoor of a supplementary delegated act,” Gewessler said at the
time. “I think it is irresponsible and unreasonable. From our point of view, it
is also not legal.” The government of Luxembourg also expressed support for the
case.
The ruling means that a deadlock over EU funding for conventional nuclear
reactors could come to an end, and is a boon to French efforts to unlock such
investments.
It also comes just after Germany last week penned an agreement with France to
develop a coherent policy accepting the inclusion of atomic power in a
low-carbon energy mix.
The move has created speculation that Berlin, which shuttered its own reactors
in the wake of the 2011 Fukushima disaster, may stop blocking efforts to direct
EU funds toward the technology.