The European Commission may be breaking the law by withholding funds from health
NGOs without explanation, 12 MEPs have warned President Ursula von der Leyen in
a letter obtained by POLITICO.
European health NGOs say they signed partnership agreements with the Commission
last year, outlining their planned activities with the understanding that they
would receive operating grants for the following financial year. These payments
cover daily overhead costs, such as salaries. But the Commission failed to issue
a call for grants as expected, while officials informally told NGOs to expect no
funding.
“Withholding funds, especially without explanation, undermines trust, possibly
breaches legal obligations, and weakens the fabric of European cooperation in
health policy. The status quo is unacceptable and cannot be allowed to
continue,” said the letter, sent July 17 and signed by MEPs from the Socialists
and Democrats, Renew and the Greens.
“Civil society and patient organisations signed agreements with the Commission
in good faith, planned their activities accordingly, and have now been left
without the operating support on which they rely,” the MEPs wrote.
Several health NGOs have already made staff redundant due to the lack of
expected funds.
The Commission’s failure to agree on its 2026 work program and subsequent
withholding of grants threatens Europe’s “democratic integrity,” the letter
continued. “If these key stakeholders, the very voice of patients, citizens, and
public health advocates, are weakened or silenced in Brussels, private
commercial interests will fill the vacuum.”
POLITICO contacted the Commission for a response to the letter. A Commission
spokesperson responded on July 17 that the final EU4Health work program is
expected to be “adopted and published very soon.”
Several health NGOs have already made staff redundant due to the lack of
expected funds. | Pool Photo by Andreas Arnold/EPA
“The Commission values the contribution of civil society and many of the funded
actions in the forthcoming work programme will involve NGOs’ participation, as
well as certain actions which will be specifically directed to NGOs,” the
spokesperson said.
CORRECTION: This article has been updated to clarify when the letter was sent.