FRANKFURT — Europeans will feel the pain of the war on Iran in their wallets
this year, even if things don’t get any worse from here on, the European Central
Bank warned on Thursday.
The ECB’s new forecasts show that inflation is set to rise to 2.6 percent this
year—well above the 1.9 percent forecast as recently as December, while growth
will slow as businesses and households have to divert more of their spending
power to essentials such as energy.
“The war in the Middle East has made the outlook significantly more uncertain,
creating upside risks for inflation and downside risks for economic growth,” the
ECB said, drawing on new quarterly forecasts for the eurozone outlook. The
forecasts were published after its policy-making Governing Council left the
Bank’s official interest rates unchanged, as expected.
The renewed hit comes just as purchasing power was starting to recover from the
last surge in prices caused by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022. That pushed
headline inflation up to 10 percent within a year.
On the upside, this forecast suggests that the ECB expects the problem to
correct itself without it needing to raise interest rates aggressively. It sees
inflation easing back towards the ECB’s 2 percent target within a couple of
years, the time horizon that the ECB uses to guide its policy decisions. The
economy is forecast to grow, albeit slightly less than previously expected: the
Bank trimmed its forecast to 0.9 percent from 1.2 percent for this year, and to
1.3 percent from 1.4 percent for next year.
Central banks are generally reluctant to respond to so-called supply shocks
because their main policy tool — control over interest rates — only works with
long and often uncertain time lags, while the geopolitical situation behind the
supply shock can change at very short notice.
However, they have to balance that against the risk of appearing complacent and
letting expectations of high inflation become self-fulfilling, as constant price
increases by retailers lead to more aggressive pay demands from workers.
In its regular policy statement, the ECB stressed that it is “closely monitoring
the situation” and will set monetary policy as appropriately. Investors have bet
that this means raising the key deposit rate twice this year, to 2.5 percent.
But policymakers around the globe have cautioned against rushing to such
conclusions.
“The thing I really want to emphasize is that nobody knows,” Federal Reserve
Chair Jerome Powell told reporters following the Fed’s decision to leave rates
unchanged on Wednesday. “It is too soon to know the scope and duration of the
potential effects on the economy.” ECB President Christine Lagarde is expected
to echo that message at her press conference later on Thursday.
However, the Bank did say that it had looked at the possible consequences of an
extended disruption of global oil and gas supplies, and warned that this “would
in the supply of oil and gas “would result in inflation being above, and growth
being below, the baseline projections.”
There is broad consensus among central bankers and private-sector economists
that the longer the conflict lasts, the more likely it is to create so-called
“stagflation” — a combination of economic stagnation and inflation.
While the ECB, like other central banks around the world, was content to adopt a
“wait-and-see” policy on Thursday, analysts don’t expect its patience to last
very long. A clearer picture is expected to emerge as soon as next month. “If
the current situation persists through to the April meeting, a hike becomes a
distinct possibility,” according to ABN AMRO’s chief economist Nick Kounis.
Tag - Europe’s economic recovery
BRUSSELS — Spain’s business sector isn’t sure Donald Trump will chicken out.
While the country’s political class may be steadfast in its defiance against the
U.S. and Israel’s war in Iran, its companies and regional leaders are scrambling
to figure out what retaliation out of Washington would look like.
The fear is that a transatlantic rift between Washington and Madrid, which
opened after Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez refused to let U.S. military planes
use jointly operated air bases on Spanish soil to attack Iran, could turn into a
complete rupture. Earlier this week, the U.S. President and his Treasury
Secretary Scott Bessent threatened to cut all trade ties with the EU’s
fourth-largest economy in retaliation.
It’s not supposed to be easy for the U.S. to bring economic pain to Spain. The
EU functions as a barrier-free common market of 27 nations, a collective
commercial entity that cannot be divided or fragmented with individual
retaliation.
But Spanish businesses aren’t taking any chances, given how vulnerable the
country would be to a U.S. trade embargo. The U.S. is Spain’s leading supplier
of fossil fuels. Over 15 percent of the oil Spain imported last year came from
the U.S., which also provided a record 44 percent of the country’s liquefied
natural gas imports last January alone. Cutting off the supply of either would
be devastating amid surging energy prices from the war in the Gulf.
Even though the U.S. accounts for less than 5 percent of Spain’s total global
exports, suspending trade relations would have a serious impact on regions like
the autonomous Basque Country, a major industrial player.
“Around 8 percent of our exports go directly to the States,” Ander Caballero,
the Basque government’s head of foreign affairs, told POLITICO during an
interview in Brussels. “We need to see how any change in policy would be
applied, but anything affecting the energy or automotive sectors, or involving
machine tools, steel, and aluminum would be a source of concern.”
Caballero noted that the region’s products were also part of larger value chains
that involve large German, French, and British companies. “Even though the U.S.
is only our fourth laregst trading partner, we could still be talking about a
hit that could amount to €1 billion.”
Basque Country President Imanol Pradales this week convened an emergency meeting
of the region’s “Industrial Defense Group,” made up of government figures,
chambers of commerce and key sectoral and business leaders, to coordinate
contingency measures against the commercial turmoil stemming from the Middle
Eastern conflict.
The rapid-response task force was created one year ago with the mission of
mitigating the regional impact of Trump’s tariff policies, which Pradales
described as a “challenge unlike anything we’ve seen in decades.” This week
marked the fourth emergency meeting of the group.
“The Basque Country cannot control the global geopolitical landscape, but we can
react quickly to protect our industry,” Pradales said. “The time it takes us to
react will determine the magnitude of the impact.”
The rush to prepare for the worst underscores Spaniards’ fear of the White
House’s arsenal of economic weapons. So far, the most popular of these weapons
has been trade tariffs. But Trump has also used sanctions to deprive his
dissenters from using American credit cards and cut off countries like Iran from
the world’s reserve currency.
Scott Bessent has no qualms with weaponizing the U.S. dollar | Magnus
Lejhall/EPA
Bessent has no qualms with weaponizing the U.S. dollar, either. Earlier this
year, he told POLITICO that sanctions and limits on access to the greenback
enabled Washington to influence other countries’ policies “without firing
bullets.”
That’s of particular concern to banks, such as Spain’s largest lender,
Santander, which last month agreed to acquire the U.S.’s Webster Financial
Corporation, a second-tier bank. The $12.2 billion deal could catapult Santander
into the top 10 American retail and commercial lenders. At the very least, a
breakdown in commercial relations between Madrid and Washington could make it
harder to secure necessary regulatory approvals.
Santander Executive Chairman Ana Botín sought to calm shareholders on Wednesday,
insisting that it was key to “look to the medium term.” While acknowledging that
the current situation was “extraordinary,” she downplayed the clash, saying:
“trade continues and is very strong.”
“Spain and the U.S. have had an amazing relationship, forever, for centuries,”
Botín told Bloomberg TV, alluding to the Spanish crown’s financial support for
George Washington in the American War of Independence, the 250th anniversary of
which is being observed this year. “The long-term relationship is strong.”
YET ANOTHER TACO?
Of course, it’s entirely possible that Trump’s vow to cut ties with Spain will
never materialize. According to market lore, whenever the risk of self-inflicted
economic pain outweighs political rhetoric, “Trump always chickens out” — or
TACO .
None of the higher tariffs he threatened to impose on Sweden, Norway, Germany,
Finland, France, the United Kingdom, and the Netherlands for their participation
in military training exercises in Greenland has been implemented.
Neither has the 200 percent tariff on French wine and champagne that Trump swore
he’d impose on Paris after French President Macron declined to join the Board of
Peace scheme to rebuild Gaza. And Madrid is still waiting to hear about the
higher tariffs the U.S. president promised to use to punish Sánchez for his
refusal to commit 5 percent of Spain’s GDP to military spending.
Sánchez this week insisted that, no matter what Trump threatens, Spain will
continue to oppose the war in Iran. José Manuel Corrales, a professor of
economics and international relations at the European University in Madrid, said
the Spanish prime minister’s stance is savvy because the U.S. president tends to
back down when countries respond to Washington by remaining firm.
“It’s worked out for Canada and México, and obviously for China,” he said. “And,
politically, it’s definitely working out for Spain’s government, which is now
being hailed for standing up to Trump and firmly saying no to this war.”
Regardless of whether Washington cuts trade relations with Madrid, Spain’s
economy is already being affected by the instability caused by the U.S. attack
on Iran. Corrales said Spain’s booming economy — which grew by 2.8 percent in
2025, and is projected to expand by over 2 percent this year — could be
undermined by surging inflation if the war lasts long.
“The truth is that we may be facing a crisis with significant repercussions,” he
said. “This latest war is already going to have consequences for the American
economy, but the Trump administration is also going to have to pay for the
damage it’s wrought on the global economy sooner or later.”
Christine Lagarde said her “baseline” is that she will stay at the European
Central Bank until her term as president ends in October 2027.
“I think that we have accomplished a lot, that I have accomplished a lot,” she
said in an interview with The Wall Street Journal, published on Friday. “We need
to consolidate and make sure that this is really solid and reliable. So my
baseline is that it will take until the end of my term.”
Her comments come two days after a report in the FT, sourced to a single person
“familiar with her thinking,” suggested the opposite. The article triggered
controversy, implying that the appointment of the next ECB president could be
moved up to deny a possible far-right president in France any say in the matter.
President Emmanuel Macron is due to step down in April next year.
Lagarde played down suggestions she would be complicit in undermining the
independence of the ECB from political influence by going along with any such
plan.
“The ECB is a very respected and credible institution, and I hope that I’ve
participated in that,” she said.
Lagarde’s comments to The Wall Street Journal are the latest in a series of
carefully caveated statements about her future that have generally left her some
wiggle room. She confirmed that she is already thinking about her next move,
telling the paper that “one of the many options” she is looking at is to take
over running the World Economic Forum. The WEF’s founder Klaus Schwab said last
year he had discussed the possibility of her leaving the Bank early to succeed
him in Davos.
Listen on
* Spotify
* Apple Music
* Amazon Music
Der EU-Sondergipfel zur Wettbewerbsfähigkeit legt Spannungen in Europa offen:
Friedrich Merz drängt auf schnellen Bürokratieabbau, um die Wirtschaftswende in
Deutschland voranzubringen. Doch ausgerechnet mit Frankreich wird es
schwieriger. Die deutsch-französische Achse wirkt angeschlagen, während Italien
bei der Frage der Deregulierung näher an Berlin rückt. Was auf dem Treffen der
Staats- und Regierungschefs morgen im Schloss Alden Biesen auf dem Spiel steht
und warum dieser Gipfel für Merz zu den wichtigsten Terminen des Jahres zählt,
analysiert Hans von der Burchard.
Mehr Insights vom EU-Sondergipfel gibt es auch in unserem PRO-Newsletter
Industrie & Handel am Morgen.
Im 200-Sekunden-Interview von Gordon Repinski geht es um die Grundsatzfrage, ob
Europa überhaupt wettbewerbsfähig sein kann. EU-Parlaments-Vizepräsidentin
Katarina Barley (SPD) erklärt, wie Bürokratieabbau und Verlässlichkeit
zusammenpassen sollen.
Dazu der Blick in den Nahen Osten: Deutschlands Position im
Israel-Palästina-Konflikt wirkt zunehmend widersprüchlich. Während Berlin die
Ausweitung der Siedlungen im Westjordanland weiter rügt, setzen deutsche
Politikerinnen vor Ort sehr unterschiedliche Akzente. Grünen-Chefin Franziska
Brantner und CDU-Politikerin Julia Klöckner reisen zeitgleich in die Region. Mit
deutlich abweichenden Botschaften. Maximilian Stascheit berichtet für POLITICO
aus Israel und den palästinensischen Gebieten, wie Brantner dort auftritt, wie
die Reaktionen vor Ort ausfallen und wie sie sich gerade außenpolitisch neu
positioniert.
Das Berlin Playbook als Podcast gibt es jeden Morgen ab 5 Uhr. Gordon Repinski
und das POLITICO-Team liefern Politik zum Hören – kompakt, international,
hintergründig. Für alle Hauptstadt-Profis: Der Berlin Playbook-Newsletter bietet
jeden Morgen die wichtigsten Themen und Einordnungen. Jetzt kostenlos
abonnieren.
Mehr von Host und POLITICO Executive Editor Gordon Repinski:
Instagram: @gordon.repinski | X: @GordonRepinski.
**(Anzeige) Eine Nachricht von Netflix: Netflix – da klingelt was? Das
Unternehmen hinter Film- und Serien-Hits wie Im Westen nichts Neues und
Adolescence nimmt euch diese Woche im Berlin Playbook Newsletter mit ”behind the
Streams”! Erfahrt, wie Netflix als fester Teil des Medienstandorts Deutschland
mit Geschichten “made in Germany” weltweit begeistert und gesellschaftliche
Debatten anstoßen kann. Eine ganze Woche für Fans von Politik und Popcorn.
Aufmerksames Lesen lohnt sich – Gibt auch was zu Gewinnen!**
POLITICO Deutschland – ein Angebot der Axel Springer Deutschland GmbH
Axel-Springer-Straße 65, 10888 Berlin
Tel: +49 (30) 2591 0 information@axelspringer.de
Sitz: Amtsgericht Berlin-Charlottenburg, HRB 196159 B
USt-IdNr: DE 214 852 390
Geschäftsführer: Carolin Hulshoff Pol, Mathias Sanchez Luna
The European Central Bank held its key deposit rate at 2 percent for a fifth
consecutive meeting on Thursday, as policymakers weighed fresh geopolitical
shocks and a stronger euro that could complicate the inflation outlook for the
eurozone.
The ECB said that its updated assessment “reconfirms that inflation should
stabilize at its 2 percent target in the medium term” and that the “economy
remains resilient.”
At the same time, the central bank warned that “the outlook is still uncertain,
owing particularly to ongoing global trade policy uncertainty and geopolitical
tensions.”
Since the ECB last met in December, global risks have intensified. U.S.
President Donald Trump threatened new tariffs — or worse — to secure control
over Greenland and launched his most aggressive attack yet of the U.S. Federal
Reserve, triggering a broad sell-off in the dollar.
That pushed the euro briefly to its highest level since 2021, raising concerns
among some ECB policymakers that currency strength could drag inflation further
below the ECB’s 2 percent target.
While data released early this week showed inflation sinking to 1.7 percent in
January, the most recent ECB staff forecasts see it returning to target by 2028.
A continued appreciation of the euro, however, risks pushing inflation below
target more durably and may thus require ECB action, French central bank chief
François Villeroy de Galhau has warned.
The euro has eased from its $1.20 peak to around $1.1780 as of Thursday,
tempering immediate concerns. But analysts said exchange-rate volatility is
likely to remain elevated, with investors watching ECB President Christine
Lagarde’s 2:45 p.m. CET press conference for clues on how policymakers are
reassessing risks — and the outlook for rates.
Listen on
* Spotify
* Apple Music
* Amazon Music
Das Berlin Playbook als Podcast gibt es morgens um 5 Uhr. Gordon Repinski und
das POLITICO-Team bringen euch jeden Morgen auf den neuesten Stand in Sachen
Politik — kompakt, europäisch, hintergründig.
Und für alle Hauptstadt-Profis:
Unser Berlin Playbook-Newsletter liefert jeden Morgen die wichtigsten Themen und
Einordnungen. Hier gibt es alle Informationen und das kostenlose Playbook-Abo.
Mehr von Berlin Playbook-Host und Executive Editor von POLITICO in Deutschland,
Gordon Repinski, gibt es auch hier:
Instagram: @gordon.repinski | X: @GordonRepinski.
POLITICO Deutschland – ein Angebot der Axel Springer Deutschland GmbH
Axel-Springer-Straße 65, 10888 Berlin
Tel: +49 (30) 2591 0
information@axelspringer.de
Sitz: Amtsgericht Berlin-Charlottenburg, HRB 196159 B
USt-IdNr: DE 214 852 390
Geschäftsführer: Carolin Hulshoff Pol, Mathias Sanchez Luna
The European Central Bank kept its key interest rate unchanged at 2 percent on
Thursday as fresh staff projections painted a brighter future ahead for the
eurozone economy after a rollercoaster year.
The Bank revised up its forecast for growth this year to 1.4 percent from 1.2
percent three months ago, reflecting the fact that the destructive trade war
with the U.S. that many feared six months ago hasn’t materialized.
It also expects the economy to grow 1.2 and 1.4 percent over the two coming
years, up from 1.0 percent and 1.3 percent previously. The ECB’s first-ever
projections for 2028 put growth at 1.4 percent.
The new numbers are likely to lock in the view that the ECB — which has now left
rates unchanged for the fourth meeting in a row — is heading for an extended
period on the sidelines. Most economists and investors now expect borrowing
costs to remain unchanged throughout 2026, barring a major economic shock.
“Economic growth is expected to be stronger than in the September projections,
driven especially by domestic demand,” the ECB said in its statement, repeating
again that it will respond to any material changes if incoming economic data
demand it.
The ECB has become gradually more upbeat since the EU decided not to escalate
trade tensions with the U.S., and since the risk of a regional conflict in the
Middle East receded. That helped the economy to grow by a stronger-than-expected
0.3 percent in the third quarter, and business surveys suggest that it has
continued to expand through the year-end.
The ECB also updated its inflation forecasts for the next two years, and now
sees inflation at 1.9 percent in 2026 and 1.8 percent in 2027. That is little
changed from 1.7 and 1.9 percent respectively three months ago. The first
inflation forecast for 2028 sees prices right back at the 2 percent level that
the ECB considers to represent price stability.
While the new forecasts will likely have secured broad backing for today’s
decision, Governing Council members have diverging views on the years ahead.
Executive Board member Isabel Schnabel said last week she believes the next move
is likely to be up, while Finland’s central bank governor Olli Rehn kept the
door to further easing ajar, warning that downside risks to the inflation
outlook still dominate.
ECB President Christine Lagarde will hold her regular press conference at 14:45
CET, and will likely give a sense of where she stands on that debate.
BRUSSELS — The European Commission on Tuesday slapped a red flag on Finland for
spending too much and warned others to tighten their belts to avoid getting the
same treatment.
The EU executive unveiled the full list of countries that are overspending, as
part of the Commission’s biannual “European Semester” that checks whether
governments are within the EU’s rules for public spending.
Red flags, known as excessive deficit procedures (EDPs), signal concerns about
countries’ financial health to investors. Brussels can impose a fine if
governments refuse to adopt measures to bring their finances back in line.
Brussels reintroduced the EU’s rules for public spending last year after the
Commission gave capitals free license during the pandemic, which plunged the
EU’s economy into the worst recession since the Second World War.
While the bloc’s economy has picked up this year, many governments are
struggling to comply with the EU’s rules amid trade tensions with the U.S. and
mounting defense budgets to deter Russian aggression.
One of the countries on Russia’s doorstep, Finland, was reprimanded for
exceeding the EU’s cap on budget deficits, which limits how much a country can
spend beyond what it collects in taxes.
Economy Commissioner Valdis Dombrovskis. | Thierry Monasse/Getty Images
The rules limit the deficit to 3 percent of a country’s economic output. Recent
tweaks to the rules allow governments to spend an additional 1.5 percent of GDP
on defense. But the numbers still don’t add up for Helsinki.
“The deficit in excess of 3 percent of GDP is not fully explained by the
increase in defense spending alone,” Economy Commissioner Valdis Dombrovskis
told reporters in Strasbourg. Germany narrowly avoided the same punishment.
Separately, the Commission checked whether governments’ expected spending in
2026 complies with their five or seven-year plans that were approved by
Brussels. So far, Croatia, Lithuania, Slovenia, Spain, Bulgaria, Hungary, the
Netherlands, and Malta aren’t doing enough. Failure to act could see Brussels
reprimand the eight countries at the next European Semester in June.
POLITICO took a deeper look at some of the key countries and graded their
current performances.
FINLAND: E
The Nordic state got a slap on the wrist from Brussels as its deficit is set to
exceed the EU’s limit for the next two years. Once a paragon of fiscal
stability, Finland is now in the same EDP basket as the indebted nations of
France, Italy, and Belgium.
As a result, Helsinki will have to reduce the deficit. That’s a tall order for a
country facing overstretched social and health budgets, as well as a ballooning
defense bill.
ROMANIA: D+
Romania can breathe a sigh of relief after today’s announcement. Dombrovskis
praised the country’s recent economic reforms and ruled out triggering the
nuclear option — a suspension of the country’s payouts from the EU budget, which
are worth billions.
But the country is not out of the woods. At 8.4 percent of GDP, its 2025 deficit
remains by far the highest in the EU, and painful domestic reforms will be
required to reduce it significantly in the years to come.
GERMANY: C
The country’s budget deficit is expected to reach 3.1 percent of GDP this year.
That’s technically a breach of the rules. But Brussels refrained from punishing
the bloc’s economic powerhouse, because the breach is “fully explained by the
increase in defense spending,” the Commission said in a statement.
But there is trouble ahead. Germany plans to continue its spending spree next
year to juice growth, only curbing expenditure later. That won’t be easy, as
China threatens the country’s export-driven economy and Chancellor Friedrich
Merz’s grand coalition needs to deliver reforms to revive growth. Berlin is
taking a huge gamble. Brussels too.
FRANCE: C-
France is in the middle of a budget crisis and is not even sure that it will
manage to adopt the 2026 budget by the end of this year. That doesn’t seem to
worry Brussels too much for the time being, especially considering that France
received its EDP red flag in 2023. The Commission found that the French budget
plans for next year are compliant with its recommendations and encouraged Paris
to continue on this path.
But not even France’s prime minister knows what his budget for next year will
look like. Sébastien Lecornu has pledged to bring the deficit down to 5 percent
of GDP. But that goal is at risk, as contradictory amendments to the draft
budget in parliament undermine the chances of a deal before Christmas.
HUNGARY: F
Hungary is facing a worrying situation because it’s not making the necessary
cuts in 2026 to exit the EDP.
For now, the Commission has merely warned Hungary to cut spending in 2026. But
if Budapest ignores such calls, Brussels might threaten to issue fines during
its next budget review in Spring.
Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán is unlikely to heed Brussels’ calls as the
country is heading to the polls next spring and he faces the risk of losing
power after almost a decade.
ITALY: B-
Has Europe’s perennial fiscal bad boy turned good? That’s what it looks like,
with Italy’s deficit set to fall to 2.6 percent of GDP next year, while
government spending is forecast to stay below the limits imposed by the EU’s
fiscal rules. That puts it on track to exit its EDP, if it can prove that debt
is set to trend lower in the long term. Other good news: Rome’s tax take is
trending above economic growth, helping to fill its coffers and pay down debt.
It’s not all good news. Italy remains the second-most indebted country in the
EU. That isn’t changing next year, with government debt expected to increase to
137.9 percent of GDP. But any positive change is welcome, especially when it’s
the class clown who is finally hitting the books.
BRUSSELS — The EU’s economy is set to expand by 1.4 percent this year, driven in
large part by Poland’s and Spain’s growth.
That’s according to the European Commission’s forecasts, presented on Monday.
Outperforming most European countries, Warsaw and Madrid are set to grow by 3.2
percent and 2.9 percent in 2025.
The EU’s economic outlook is a slight improvement from last spring’s forecast at
1.1 percent. The Commission expects the bloc’s economy to continue growing at a
rate of 1.4 percent next year, despite the U.S.’ slapping 15 percent tariffs on
European exports.
In further good news, the unemployment rate is set to remain below 6 percent
through 2027, while inflation will shrink to 2.2 percent within the same time
period. Economy Commissioner Valdis Dombrovskis urged the bloc to capitalize on
the momentum.
“Now, given the challenging external context, the EU must take resolute action
to unlock domestic growth,” such as “simplifying regulation, completing the
Single Market, and boosting innovation,” Dombrovskis said in a statement.
In a striking reversal, the poster boys of the eurozone crisis — Portugal,
Greece, Cyprus, Ireland, and Spain — are set to outperform countries such as
Germany, Finland, and Austria that were once seen as economic models.
In a worrying sign for Europe, its three largest economies — Germany, France,
and Italy — are set to experience weak growth over the coming years. Once the
engine of European growth, Germany is set to expand by 0.2 percent in 2025 and
1.2 percent in 2026 and 2027.
Italy is estimated to grow at an even more sluggish pace — 0.4 percent in 2025
and 0.8 percent in 2026 and 2027 — despite being the main beneficiary of the
EU’s post-COVID recovery program.
This stands in contrast to the strong economic growth in 2025 in Southern and
Eastern countries such as Malta (4 percent), Bulgaria (3 percent), Lithuania
(2.4 percent) and Croatia (3.2 percent).
VIENNA — Donald Trump’s trade war has been less damaging for Europe’s economy
than widely feared, and there is a hope that a stable recovery is underway,
European Central Bank governing council member Martin Kocher said.
“We have not seen the strong reduction in growth rates and the inflationary
effects of the trade conflicts that were anticipated in March and April,” the
Austrian National Bank governor told POLITICO in an interview on Wednesday.
On the same day that a closely-watched business survey pointed to an unexpected
and marked pickup in activity in October, Kocher suggested there were emerging
signs of an economic pickup.
Kocher, who served as economy minister before joining the central bank in
September, nonetheless warned against complacency. “I don’t want to sugarcoat
what we are seeing,” he said. “This is the highest level of tariffs since the
1930s, and there will be effects on the world economy.”
The impact on the eurozone will be exceptionally difficult to predict because we
have not experienced anything similar in nearly 100 years, Kocher said, adding
that this was the primary reason for diverging views about the ideal monetary
policy path ahead on the ECB’s governing council.
Falling inflation has allowed the ECB to cut its key deposit rate eight times
since the middle of last year, bringing it down from a record-high 4 percent to
2 percent currently — a level that the Bank says is no longer restricting the
economy.
A behavioral economist rather than a monetary one, Kocher is one of the newest
faces on the governing council, having succeeded Robert Holzmann earlier this
year. Most analysts expect a more moderate approach from him than from the
veteran hawk Holzmann, who was often the lone dissenter on the rate-setting
body.
The governor’s office leaves no doubt there is a change in style underfoot — the
wooden desk replaced by a modern, height-adjustable table and new, colorful
paintings by Austrian artists Wolfgang Hollegha and Hans Staudacher on the wall.
While policymakers unanimously agreed to keep interest rates on hold last week,
ECB President Christine Lagarde revealed that “there are different positions and
different views” on whether the Bank may yet have to cut them one more time.
“The difficulty is to assess whether most of the effects of the trade conflicts
have already materialized or whether we will see them trickle down in the
economy over the next couple of months and perhaps even years,” he said. “I’m
convinced that we’ll see more effects over time. But whether they will be
overall inflationary, or rather disinflationary in the euro area, is difficult
to tell.”
RISKY OUTLOOK
Kocher explained it’s reasonable to expect deflationary pressure from the
rerouting of trade from China to Europe that was flowing to the U.S. before the
trade conflict began, but it’s equally plausible that geopolitical conflicts may
hamper supply chains and boost prices.
And things can change very fast. “Last week’s APEC summit with some interim
agreement between the U.S. and China might have changed the outlook again,” he
noted.
While policymakers unanimously agreed to keep interest rates on hold last week,
ECB President Christine Lagarde revealed that “there are different positions and
different views” on whether the Bank may yet have to cut them one more time. |
Nikolay Doychinov/AFP via Getty Images
At the summit, the U.S. and China committed to lowering the temperature in their
trade and tech rivalry. The so-called “Gyeongju Declaration” called for “robust
trade and investment” and committed leaders to deepen economic cooperation.
In this environment, “we have to wait and see to what extent [risks]
materialize” as it’s difficult to take rate decisions “primarily based on the
risk outlook,” Kocher said.
As things stand, he said, the ECB would need to “see some risk materializing
that would reduce … the GDP projection to a significant extent, and that would
lead perhaps to some disinflationary effects” before it discussed cutting again.
The governing council next meets in December, when a new set of forecasts will
include estimates for growth and inflation in 2028 for the first time.
Kocher warned against placing too much emphasis on the 2028 numbers, which many
economists and investors focus on as an indication of whether the Bank is on
track to meet its medium-term inflation target.
While the forecast will offer more certainty about the outlook for 2026 and
2027, that for 2028 will be little more than “indicative,” he argued. “You
always have to take projections with a grain of salt. And the further away the
projection horizon, the larger the grain of salt.”
GREEN BATTLE CONTINUES
Kocher was speaking on the day that a majority of the EU’s 27 governments
decided to water down their collective target for pollution reduction, seen by
many as a sign that political momentum has swung after half a decade of green
victories on climate policy.
But Kocher fiercely defended the ECB’s commitment to green central banking.
“Whatever is decided today, there’s no significant change in the targets of the
European Union to become climate neutral in the near future,” Kocher said. And
so long as it does not interfere with the ECB’s inflation-targeting mandate, the
ECB has the “freedom” to support those objectives.
He said the governing council had reaffirmed the view, even in the last couple
of months, that it is essential to take climate risks into account in its
projections, citing the massive impact that extreme weather events can have on
growth and inflation.
In contrast to his predecessor, Kocher also backs the inclusion of a climate
criterion in the Bank’s collateral framework, a step that could one day make it
more expensive for polluting companies than for green ones to borrow money.
Critics of green central banking have argued that it is up to elected
politicians, rather than central bankers, to create incentives for green
business. But Kocher, a former downhill racer who has seen Austria’s key tourism
sector struggle with an ever-shorter ski season, is unconcerned. “As long as it
does not create a trade-off with our inflation target, I am perfectly fine with
it,” he said.