Winter vacation can’t start soon enough for Pedro Sánchez.
Spain’s governing Socialist Party is being battered by a deluge of sexual
harassment scandals that is prompting the resignation or dismissal of mayors,
regional leaders and even officials employed in the prime minister’s palace.
Within the party, there’s open recognition that its self-proclaimed status as
the country’s premier progressive political entity is being severely undermined.
The scandals are also provoking major fractures within Sánchez’s coalition
government and parliamentary alliance, with even his most reliable collaborators
demanding he make major changes — or call snap elections.
Deputy Prime Minister Yolanda Díaz, whose far-left Sumar party is the junior
partner in Sánchez’s coalition government, said on Friday that a “profound
Cabinet reshuffle” was needed to make a clean break with the rot. Aitor Esteban,
president of the Basque Nationalist Party — one of the government’s most
reliable parliamentary partners — said if the Socialists fail to halt the “daily
hemorrhage of news stories,” snap elections must be held.
Spain’s Socialists are no strangers to scandal, having spent the past two years
dealing with endless headline-grabbing revelations detailing the alleged
embezzlement of public funds by former Transport Minister José Luis Ábalos and
party boss Santos Cerdán — both of whom maintain their innocence. Sánchez has so
far weathered the storms by insisting the corruption cases are limited to just a
few bad apples, and arguing that only his government can keep the country on a
socially liberal track.
But the scale of the sexual harassment scandals revealed in recent days — which
have coincided with anti-corruption raids in government buildings — represent an
unprecedented challenge for the prime minister. There are serious doubts that
Sánchez’s “stay-the-course” playbook will suffice to see his government through
this latest political earthquake.
GROWING SKEPTICISM
When Sánchez came to power in 2018 he boasted that he led “the most feminist
government in history,” with 11 of the country’s 17 ministries led by women.
Over the past seven years his successive administrations have passed legislation
to ensure gender balance in key sectors, fight gender-based violence and promote
gender equality abroad.
But the actions of some of Sa´nchez’s fellow Socialists are fueling growing
skepticism about whether the governing party truly respects women. Last summer
the prime minister apologized to supporters and expressed his “shame” after the
release of wiretaps on which the Spanish police alleged former Transport
Minister Ábalos could be heard describing his trysts with female sex workers.
Ábalos, for his part, claims the recordings have been manipulated and the voice
they capture is not his.
Weeks later, sexual harassment complaints against another of the prime
minister’s long-time collaborators, Francisco Salazar, forced his resignation on
the very day he was meant to assume a new role as one of the party’s top
leaders. That scandal resurfaced this month after Spanish media revealed the
party had slow-walked its investigation into the alleged abuses committed by
Salazar, who maintains his innocence.
Last week Sánchez said he took “personal responsibility” for the botched
investigation and apologized for not reaching out to Salazar’s victims. He also
ordered the dismissal of Antonio Hernández, an official employed in the prime
minister’s palace whom Salazar’s victims had singled out as the harasser’s
alleged “accomplice.” Hernández denies the accusation.
Sánchez’s attempts to contain the situation don’t appear to have quelled
indignation over the party’s failure to address Salazar’s alleged abuses, and
the frustration has resulted in a version of the #MeToo movement within the
Socialists’ ranks.
Deputy Prime Minister Yolanda Díaz, whose far-left Sumar party is the junior
partner in Sánchez’s coalition government, said on Friday that a “profound
Cabinet reshuffle” was needed to make a clean break with the rot. | Perez
Meca/Getty Images
Over recent days, the party’s boss in Torremolinos has been suspended from his
post after being denounced for sexual harassment by an alderman, who also
accused the Socialists of failing to act when she first reported the alleged
abuses last summer. Belalcázar’s mayor has also stepped down following the
publication of sexually explicit messages to a municipal employee, and the
launch of an investigation for alleged harassment has prompted the Socialists’
deputy secretary in the province of Valencia to leave the party.
The three officials deny the accusations against them.
So, too, does José Tomé, who insists the multiple sexual harassment complaints
that resulted in his resignation as president of the Provincial Council of Lugo
this week are completely unfounded. The admission of regional leader José Ramón
Gómez Besteiro that he had been aware of the allegations against Tomé for months
prompted the party’s regional equality czar to step down in disgust, and are
generating doubts regarding the Socialists’ political future in the Galicia.
TROUBLED TIMES
The barrage of sexual harassment complaints are a major problem for Sánchez.
Women are a key segment of his party’s voter base: Female voters tend to
participate in elections to a greater extent than men, and have historically
mobilized in favor of the Socialists. But surveys by the country’s national
polling institute reveal that women are becoming increasingly disenchanted with
the party. In a poll carried out shortly after the Ábalos recordings were
released, support for the Socialists among female voters dropped from 26.2
percent to 19.4 percent.
Pilar Bernabé, the party’s equality secretary, admitted on Friday that the wave
of harassment complaints marked a “before and after” moment for the Socialists,
who now had to prove that they have zero tolerance for abuse. “Sexism is
incompatible with Socialism,” she added.
The challenges to the party’s bona fides are less than welcome at a moment when
it faces multiple corruption investigations. In addition to the ongoing probes
into Ábalos and Cerdán — both of whom were ordered jailed without bond last
month — this week former Socialist Party member Leire Díez along with Vicente
Fernández, the former head of the state-owned agency charged with managing
Spain’s business holdings, were arrested for alleged embezzlement and influence
peddling. At their respective bail hearings, Díez invoked her right to remain
silent, while Fernández denied any wrongdoing.
Days later, the elite anti-corruption unit of Spain’s Civil Guard raided several
agencies managed by the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Ecological
Transition and the Demographic Challenge, as well as the headquarters of the
Spanish Postal Service, as part of a related investigation into the alleged
rigging of public contracts.
CAN SÁNCHEZ CARRY ON?
During a campaign event headlined by Sa´nchez on Sunday, party members urged the
prime minister to act. “Take a firm hand to the harassers, the womanizers, the
chauvinists!” said Irene Pozas, head of the Socialist Youth in the province of
Cáceres. “Don’t hold back, Pedro: The women of the Socialist Party must not have
any cause for regret!”
Pedro Sánchez may be hoping for relief from the scandals during the upcoming
holiday break in Spain, but it’s unclear if his party, and the weak coalition
government it leads, will be able to recover. | Marcos del Mazo/Getty Images
While admitting shortcomings in the party’s internal mechanisms for handling
complaints, Sánchez defended the Socialists’ determination to “act decisively
and transparently” to tackle sexism and corruption. The prime minister also
defiantly asserted his will to carry on, telling supporters that “governing
means facing the music and staying strong through thick and thin.”
Sánchez may be hoping for relief from the scandals during the upcoming holiday
break in Spain, but it’s unclear if his party, and the weak coalition government
it leads, will be able to recover. Although the prime minister insists he
intends to govern until the current legislative term ends in 2027, his inability
to pass a fresh budget and wider difficulties in passing legislation jeopardize
that goal.
The Socialists’ parliamentary allies are reluctant to see Sánchez fall because
they know snap elections will almost certainly produce a right-wing government
influenced by the far-right Vox party. But they are also wary of being
associated misogyny and fraud — especially if voters may soon be heading to the
polls.
“Stopping the far right and the extreme right is always a non-negotiable duty,
but it is not achieved merely by saying it, but by demonstrating that we are
better,” tweeted the president of the Republican Left of Catalonia, Oriol
Junqueras. “Those who abuse and become corrupt cannot regenerate democracy.”
Tag - Spanish politics
Spanish Attorney General Álvaro García Ortiz resigned Monday, stepping down
before a judicial ruling banning him from holding public office for two years
went into effect.
Spain’s Supreme Court last week convicted García Ortiz of leaking details of a
tax probe involving the partner of Madrid’s regional leader Isabel Díaz Ayuso, a
rising star among the country’s conservative voters.
The outgoing attorney general denies leaking the information, and several
journalists who published articles about the probe testified he was not their
source. Although the court announced García Ortiz’s guilty verdict within days
of his trial’s conclusion, the panel of judges who tried him has yet to publish
the legal reasoning behind the ruling.
In a resignation letter addressed to Justice Minister Félix Bolaños, García
Ortiz said that his “deep respect” for judicial decisions and “desire to protect
the Spanish Public Prosecutor’s Office” obliged him to step down immediately.
Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez on Sunday said he “regretted” the
conviction and affirmed his belief in the outgoing attorney general’s innocence.
But he also underscored the sanctity of the rule of law in Spain, insisting the
government “respects rulings and abides by them.”
Sánchez added that there were legal channels by which García Ortiz can “address
any controversial aspects of this ruling.” The outgoing attorney general could
file an appeal with the country’s Constitutional Court, or even seek to
challenge it beyond Spain’s borders.
García Ortiz’s conviction has generated immense controversy in Spain, with
opinions split largely along ideological lines. While the center-right People’s
Party and far-right Vox group have cheered the court’s decision, Sánchez’s
ruling coalition has rallied around him, accusing the judiciary of being
weaponized by conservative political forces. Groups less friendly to Sánchez
have also sided with with García Ortiz, citing their own, unhappy experiences
with alleged “lawfare” in Spain.
Last week the Catalan separatist Junts party — which recently staged a public
breakup with the Spanish government — said it was unsurprised by the ruling
“because we know how the Supreme Court works.” The usually critical, far-left
Podemos party on Monday said the attorney general’s exit was the result of a
“judicial coup.”
Spain’s Supreme Court has just taken its battle with Prime Minister Pedro
Sánchez to a whole new level.
The court on Tuesday banned Attorney General Álvaro García Ortiz from holding
public office for two years for allegedly leaking details of a tax probe
involving the partner of Madrid’s regional leader Isabel Díaz Ayuso, a rising
star among the country’s conservative voters.
Justice Minister Félix Bolaños said that the government was obliged “to abide by
the sentence” and appoint a new attorney general. But he stressed the
executive’s disagreement with the conviction, and reaffirmed its belief in
García Ortiz’s innocence.
The ruling risks turning that feud into a constitutional crisis, with the
judiciary seemingly taking aim at members of the executive running Europe’s
fourth-largest economy. The clash has taken a toll on Sánchez, who has long
claimed to be the target of “lawfare,” accusing conservative judges of pursuing
baseless cases against his allies and family.
Last year the prime minister briefly considered stepping down after his wife was
named as the target of a judicial investigation that is ongoing, but widely
considered to be baseless. His brother, meanwhile, is due to face trial next
year on influence-peddling charges linked to a civil service post he took before
Sánchez came to power.
Both of the prime minister’s family members deny wrongdoing and say the cases
are politically motivated.
A FAKE STORY AND AN ALLEGED LEAK
The case against García Ortiz dates to early 2024, when Spanish media began
reporting on a tax fraud investigation into Ayuso’s partner, businessman Alberto
González Amador.
In March of last year, Spanish daily El Mundo published an article alleging the
Madrid prosecutor’s office had offered González Amador a plea deal — a fake news
story that Ayuso’s chief of staff, Miguel Ángel Rodríguez, later admitted he
spread to selected journalists.
When reporters sought confirmation, the prosecutor’s office clarified that it
was actually the defense who proposed a plea deal by which the accused would
admit to committing tax fraud in exchange for a reduced sentence. But several
journalists published articles with that information ahead of the
clarification’s release, sparking an investigation into whether emails between
prosecutors and González Amador had been leaked.
In a surprise twist, García Ortiz was charged over the alleged disclosure.
At last week’s Supreme Court trial, the attorney general denied leaking the
messages, with his defense attorneys demonstrating that dozens of officials had
access to the allegedly leaked emails. Several journalists also testified that
García Ortiz was not their source.
JUDICIAL TENSION
García Ortiz’s case was tried by a panel of seven judges, with the five
conservative judges backing the conviction and the two progressives dissenting.
The verdict was announced unusually quickly — even before the court had drafted
its legal reasoning.
It remains unclear how the judges will justify the decision, but it’s possible
they were swayed by González Amador’s lawyer, who argued that the journalists
who testified had a vested interest in protecting García Ortiz — if he was their
leaker.
In a surprise twist, García Ortiz was charged over the alleged disclosure. |
Gustavo de la Paz/Europa Press via Getty Images
Speaking later at an event marking the 50th anniversary of dictator Francisco
Franco’s death, Sánchez appeared to allude to the case, warning that “democracy
is not a permanent conquest: it is a privilege we must defend every day from
unfounded nostalgia, economic interests and attacks that constantly evolve.”
“Today, these attacks take the form of disinformation campaigns and abuses of
power,” he added.
The leader of the conservative opposition, People’s Party boss Alberto Núñez
Feijóo, cheered the conviction, describing the attorney general as “someone who
was supposed to be prosecuting crimes, but instead committed them.” He demanded
Sánchez step down immediately.
But Sánchez’s ruling coalition has rallied around him, accusing the judiciary of
being weaponized by conservative political forces.
Health Minister Mónica García, from the left-wing Más Madrid party, called the
ruling an “affront” to all citizens.
“This is a lethal blow to the rule of law, the requirement to present
incriminating evidence, [and] the presumption of innocence,” she added.
Carlos Mazón, the center-right president of Spain’s Valencia region, announced
his resignation Monday, caving to pressure to take political responsibility for
the devastating floods in which 229 people died one year ago.
It became evident last week that if Spain’s conservatives want to keep governing
in the region, Mazón had to go. Backed by the People’s Party (PP) leadership,
the regional president had been able to resist the tens of thousands of
Valencians who called for his resignation in mass protests over the past 12
months.
But the breaking point came at last Wednesday’s state funeral for the victims,
at which King Felipe VI and other bewildered dignitaries watched mourning
families shout insults at Mazón, whom they referred to as an “assassin.” After a
weekend of “reflection” and a talk with PP leader Alberto Núñez Feijóo, the
regional president admitted Monday he couldn’t “do it anymore.”
Mazón is seen as the embodiment of the regional government’s botched response to
the catastrophe.
In the lead-up to the floods, the PP politician downplayed the threat posed by
the severe weather forecast in the region. It was later revealed that Mazón had
remained at a private lunch with a female journalist as the storm raged and did
not show up at the crisis center until after dark. His absence is cited as a
factor in the regional authority’s decision to delay sending an SMS alert
warning locals of the danger until 8:28 p.m., when most of the victims had
already drowned.
Within days of the disaster, victims’ families began demanding that Mazón take
political responsibility for the disaster and resign. But despite the mounting
evidence that the regional government had mismanaged the crisis, PP leader
Feijóo backed the center-right politician.
Feijóo’s initial willingness to support Mazón reflects Valencia’s importance for
the PP. The region is one of the fastest growing in Spain, and its conquest by
the conservatives in 2023 was seen as a major victory for the party. But the
center-right governs in minority in Valencia, and there were fears that Mazón’s
ouster could jeopardize the hard-won prize. So Spain’s conservatives were
mobilized to shift blame onto center-left political figures like Prime Minister
Pedro Sánchez, then-Deputy Prime Minister Teresa Ribera, and even the scientists
at the country’s National Meteorological Agency.
Over the past 12 months, however, Spanish courts exonerated both Sánchez and
Ribera, underscoring that the regional government was the only entity authorized
to manage the crisis. Spain’s state forecasters have similarly been cleared,
with evidence proving their warnings about the coming storms were ignored.
In the meantime, the Valencian judge leading the probe meant to establish blame
for the disaster has indicted members of Mazón’s team, and only spared the
center-right politician because his presidential status means he can only be
indicted by Valencia’s High Court of Justice.
Mazón on Monday recognized that he had made “mistakes,” but bitterly complained
that he was the victim of a “brutal campaign” to force his ouster. He declined
to dissolve the Valencian parliament and call snap elections, or to resign his
post as a lawmaker, ensuring he maintains a degree of judicial immunity.
Catalan separatists voted to sever ties with Spanish Prime Minister Pedro
Sánchez’s Socialists, further weakening his minority government.
Citing a “lack of will” from the Socialists, separatist Junts’ party leader
Carles Puigdemont said Sánchez had failed to carry out the promises made in 2023
when he persuaded Junts’ seven lawmakers in the Spanish parliament to back his
bid to remain in power.
The break is dire for Sánchez, whose government has no hope of passing
legislation without the support of Junts’ lawmakers. The prime minister has not
been able to get a new budget approved since the start of this term and has
instead governed with extensions of the 2022 budget and EU recovery cash.
Without the backing of Catalan separatist lawmakers, the Socialists have no way
to secure the additional funds needed to comply with U.S. President Donald
Trump’s demands Madrid increase its defense spending.
Puigdemont said the Socialists no longer “have the capacity to govern” and
challenged Sánchez to explain how he intends to remain in power.
But the exiled separatist leader appeared to reject teaming up with the
center-right People’s Party and the far-right Vox group to back a censure motion
to topple Sánchez outright.
“We will not support any government that does not support Catalonia, this one or
any other,” the separatist leader said, apparently ruling out collaboration with
the parties, both of which are opposed to the separatist movement and its
nationalist objectives.
INCOMPLETE COMMITMENTS
During his press conference in Perpignan, Puigdemont reprimanded Sánchez and his
Socialist Party for failing to keep its promises.
In exchange for Junts’ crucial support in 2023, the prime minister’s party
committed to passing an amnesty law benefiting hundreds of separatists and other
measures. While many of those vows — among them, new rules allowing the use of
Catalan in the Spanish parliament — have been fulfilled, others are pending.
The Spanish parliament passed the promised amnesty bill last year, but its full
application has since been halted by the courts. Spain’s Supreme Court has
specifically blocked Puigdemont — who fled Spain following the failed 2017
Catalan independence referendum and has since lived in exile in Waterloo,
Belgium — from benefiting from the law, citing pending embezzlement charges.
Carles Puigdemont said the Socialists no longer “have the capacity to govern.” |
Gloria Sanchez/Getty Images
The lack of change in his status quo is a source of deep frustration for the
separatist leader, who in a 2024 interview with POLITICO said his greatest
desire was to “go home to Girona, to enjoy my homeland and be with my wife and
daughters … to lead a normal life that will allow me to become anonymous once
again.”
Puigdemont also cited the Socialists’ inability to get Catalan recognized as an
official EU language as a reason for the break in relations. Spanish diplomats
have spent the past two years lobbying counterparts in Brussels and national
capitals and recently persuaded Germany to back the proposal. But numerous
countries remain opposed to the idea, arguing the move would cost the EU
millions of euros in new translation and interpretation fees and embolden
Breton, Corsican or Russian-speaking minorities to seek similar recognition.
The separatist leader added that the Sánchez government’s reluctance to give
Catalonia jurisdiction over immigration within that region proved that although
there might be “personal trust” between the Socialists and Junts’
representatives, “political trust” was lacking.
Junts’ members are now called upon to either ratify or reject the executive
committee’s decision in an internal consultation that concludes Thursday. The
party’s supporters, who include Puigdemont’s most devoted followers, are
expected to overwhelmingly back the move to break with the Socialists.
Over the past two years Junts has hardly been an unwavering source of support
for Sánchez’s weak minority government. The party has declined to back key bills
and stressed that it is not part of the “progressive” coalition composed of the
Socialists and the left-wing Sumar party, but rather a pragmatic partner that is
solely focused on Catalonia’s interests.
At a meeting of the Socialist Party leadership in Madrid on Monday, Sánchez
insisted the party should “remain open to dialogue and willing to engage” with
Junts.
Following Puigdemont’s speech, Science and Universities Minister Diana Morant
expressed doubts “Junts’ electorate voted in favor of letting Vox or the
People’s Party govern” and said the Catalan separatists needed to “choose
whether they want Spain to represent progress or regression.”
Spain will attempt Monday to reenergize the EU’s stalled proposal to end
seasonal clock changes and demand Brussels fulfill its promise to end daylight
saving time.
“As you know, the clocks will change again this week and I, frankly, no longer
see the point in it,” Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez said in a video
posted on X Monday morning.
“In all the surveys in which Spaniards and Europeans are asked, the majority are
against changing the time,” he said. “Moreover, there’s plenty of scientific
evidence that shows it barely helps to save energy and has a negative impact on
people’s health and lives.”
The bloc’s transport, telecoms and energy ministers have traditionally handled
discussions regarding the EU’s time policies, which can affect the functioning
of the all-important single market and have an impact on power use and transport
safety.
The issue was not scheduled to be debated at Monday’s ministerial summit in
Luxembourg but, upon his arrival at the meeting, Spanish Secretary of State for
Energy Joan Groizard announced he had requested its inclusion on the agenda.
“The energy system is changing a lot, and it’s important to reopen the debate to
find a solution that works as well as possible,” Groizard said.
Representatives from northern EU members including Finland and Poland have
repeatedly raised concerns about clock-changing, citing data which shows the
practice has negative physical or mental effects on an estimated 20 percent of
Europe’s population.
Indeed, 84 percent of the 6.4 million Europeans who participated in a 2018
European Commission public consultation on the matter said the bloc should put
an end to daylight saving time.
In his social media post, Sánchez said it was high time for the EU to carry out
the proposal announced by then-European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker
during his 2018 State of the Union address in the European Parliament.
“Clock-changing must stop,” Juncker told lawmakers, insisting that daylight
saving shifts would end by October 2019 at latest. “We are out of time.”
But Juncker’s proposal irritated national leaders, who questioned the
Commission’s mandate for proposing such a shift, let alone imposing a short
timeline for its costly implementation.
Then-Portuguese Prime Minister António Costa — who became the president of the
European Council last year — rejected the idea altogether, citing the advice of
technical experts who said the change would be detrimental to his country’s
citizens. Greece, too, was opposed to the change.
The split among national leaders permitted daylight saving to survive Juncker’s
2019 deadline and the European Parliament’s later call for time changes to end
by 2021. It’s unclear if Spain’s effort is quixotic: to secure the Council’s
endorsement of the proposal, it requires the backing of a qualified majority of
member countries.
Sánchez will need to convince 15 out of the bloc’s 27 member countries, or a
group of countries representing at least 65 percent of the EU’s population, to
back the idea — and hope fewer than four capitals oppose it outright.
Seasonal clock-changing was first introduced in Europe during World War I in a
bid to conserve coal, but was abandoned after the conflict ended. Similar energy
concerns prompted most countries to reintroduce the scheme during World War II,
and in response to the 1970s global oil crisis.
In 1980 the then-European Communities issued its first directive on time
arrangements to ensure all EU members followed the practice and made the
biannual switch at the same date and time. The current EU rules, which have been
in place since 2001, specify EU member countries move their clocks forward one
hour at 1 a.m. on the last Sunday of March, and wind back one hour on the last
Sunday in October.
St. George’s Day in Catalonia — commemorating the slaying of an evil dragon — is
meant to be a celebration of love, accompanied by romantic exchanges of books
and roses. This April, a highly political banking deal loomed unexpectedly large
over festivities.
For the iconic Catalan lender Banc Sabadell, the dragon to be killed was
Madrid-headquartered banking giant BBVA, which is pressing a hostile offer to
buy it for €17 billion in stock.
The catchphrase of Banc Sabadell’s ads, sung on radio and TV, was: “It’s April
again, the insatiable dragon is here. If we kill him, he doesn’t seem to learn.
What should we do to make him understand?” Prominent Catalan personalities then
proposed various ways to fend off dragon attacks.
Tensions are now at an all-time high as Barcelona and Madrid await the results
on Oct. 10 of the second takeover offer by BBVA, at a higher price per share, to
Banc Sabadell’s shareholders.
To many Catalans, the deal is viscerally political — and not simply a matter of
stock valuations. While the EU may be pushing for more bank mergers to ensure
European finance houses are more internationally competitive, the idea of losing
Banc Sabadell to interests in Madrid is anathema.
Banc Sabadell has a symbolic cachet in Catalonia. Were the region to win
independence, it would be an important economic motor for the nation. It is
critical to funding the region’s all-important small- and medium-sized
enterprises.
This makes the deal a headache for Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez. Although the
takeover has been approved by Spain’s antitrust authority, he has sought to
attach extra hurdles to it to please his Catalan nationalist allies, who are
vital to the survival of his fragile government.
EMOTIONAL ELEMENT
Catalonia’s Economy Minister Alícia Romero supports the Spanish government’s
extra restrictions on the deal — which include a three-year postponement of the
merger once BBVA acquires a majority of shares. During these three years BBVA
would not be able to fire staff, close offices or merge its IT systems or
accounts, keeping Banc Sabadell as a separate entity. That makes the merger more
risky for BBVA.
“It is true that there is an emotional element here,” she told POLITICO. “This
is a bank that was born in Sabadell, a prominent textile city, of the Catalan
bourgeoisie, which has always been committed to financing SMEs” — a sector she
called Catalonia’s “economic fabric.”
Romero is member of the Catalan Socialist Party and an ally of Sánchez.
Still, she argued the core objection to the deal was that it would reduce the
number of banks in the region, which would lessen competition and worsen
conditions for customers.
Catalonia’s Economy Minister Alícia Romero supports the Spanish government’s
extra restrictions on the deal. | David Zorrakino/Europa Press via Getty Images
“If Banc Sabadell disappeared, it could leave many SMEs without this financing,
without these possibilities to grow and open up to markets,” she said.
Romero also argued that the government would not like to see the bank’s
decision-making power shift to Madrid, since that could mean job losses in
Catalonia and office closures.
THE EU WANTS MERGERS
For its part, BBVA says it doing exactly what the EU wants.
BBVA chair Carlos Torres has resolutely defended the deal, insisting that both
Europe and Spain need financial powerhouses of scale to compete on global
markets. He stressed “both BBVA and Banco Sabadell shareholders will become the
owners of a bank better prepared for the future.”
In response to Banc Sabadell’s dragon ads, BBVA launched a rival campaign called
“Let’s Move Forward,” featuring actors portraying shareholders from both banks
discussing reasons why the merger would benefit both sides.
BBVA is opting to sweeten the deal by announcing the highest dividends the
company has ever distributed — including for Banc Sabadell’s shareholders who
decide to swap shares for its own.
While Catalans have been the most outspoken opponents of the deal, no major
Spanish party has come out strongly in favor. The center right People’s Party
and far-right Vox have largely remained tight-lipped, just warning against the
concentration of the banking sector.
The deal is also a particularly public and political clash because of the
importance of Banc Sabadell’s retail shareholders, who make up about 48 percent
of its owners.
“Banc Sabadell’s shareholders are, for the most part, SMEs and retailers,” said
Iñigo de Barrón, former president of the Spanish association of economy
journalists, who covered banks for more than 20 years. “We’re talking about the
middle class, people who feel that if they end up in the hands of a very large
bank that doesn’t know them at all, it’s not a pleasant thing.”
“It’s a sentimental takeover bid, the most emotional I’ve ever seen,” he added.
MADRID VS. BARCELONA VS. BRUSSELS
After losing most of their small banks in the wake of the eurozone financial
crisis — many of them absorbed into BBVA — Catalans still carry the trauma of
seeing outside giants swallow their economic power.
“In the last 20 years, the entire Catalan banking and credit system has been
dismantled,” said Albert Batet, spokesperson of the pro-independence Junts
party.
The merger “means a loss of economic weight for Catalonia compared to the
economic weight of Madrid, which is where BBVA has its headquarters, a bank from
Madrid, with a Spanish identity,” Batet added.
Their rivals from the Catalan Republican Left, also pro-independence, agree.
“Weakening the Catalan financial system will ultimately result in job losses,
affect the financing of SMEs, and — seen from the perspective of the state — it
benefits the concentration of economic power in Madrid and its local economic
network, and we don’t like that,” said Isaac Albert, spokesperson for the party.
“It’s not just about sentimental reasons — although of course, we are concerned
about losing a Catalan bank — it’s mainly about the real impact this has,” he
said.
Catalan politicians say they support Europe’s vision of trying to foster big
banks to compete with other global actors, but they don’t want to take that step
themselves.
They argue such mergers should be among banks from different countries rather
than within one member country, because, they say, that simply weakens the
consumer’s position by reducing competition.
“Starting with two Catalan-Spanish domestic banks doesn’t seem like the solution
to me,” said Catalan Economy Minister Romero.
“The solution has to come from the top; it needs a very strong and ambitious
strategy from all countries. It’s not that we have to be the ones to start,” she
added.
MADRID — Spain’s tough stance on Israel may have caused anger in Jerusalem but
it has provided a popularity boost for under-pressure Prime Minister Pedro
Sánchez.
The last two weeks have seen Sánchez’s left-wing coalition ramp up its criticism
of Israel, triggering a diplomatic spat and a fierce war of words. Having become
the most senior European leader to describe Israel’s actions as “genocide” in
June, earlier this month the socialist prime minister announced a series of
measures that included a weapons embargo and the banning of two Israeli
government ministers from Spain.
Israel responded by barring two of Sánchez’s ministers from entering the country
while labelling the Spanish government as antisemitic.
Sánchez then praised pro-Palestinian protesters who repeatedly disrupted the
Vuelta a España cycling race over the involvement of an Israeli team,
culminating in the cancellation of the final stage and injuries to 22 police
officers amid chaotic scenes in Madrid.
“Mr Sánchez and his communist ministers encouraged the violence,” said Gideon
Sa’ar, the Israeli foreign minister.
Sánchez has since called for Israel to be barred from all major international
sporting events, and public broadcaster RTVE has said Spain will not take part
in the Eurovision Song Contest if Israel competes.
“I’m proud to be part of a government … that is making the world move,” said
Óscar López, minister for digital transformation. Israel responded by saying
Sánchez was “demonizing” the country and was “on the wrong side of history.”
Sánchez has been among Europe’s most outspoken critics of Israel over its
response to the Oct. 7, 2023 attacks by Hamas, while also slamming the EU’s
failure to act. He expressed concerns about civilian deaths in Gaza directly to
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in November of that year, and in 2024
his government acknowledged a Palestinian state.
DOMESTIC CONCERNS
At home, however, Sánchez has been reeling in recent months as his fragile
minority government has faced a series of corruption probes and unfavorable
headlines. An increasingly strident position on Gaza has provided a badly needed
fillip.
“He’s at a critical juncture, the worst moment of his tenure, and he has managed
to use this issue as a way of reconnecting with his voters and filling a
political void,” said Lluís Orriols, a political scientist at Carlos III
University.
In June, Sánchez was forced to apologize after the release of audio recordings
featuring his party’s No. 3, Santos Cerdán, that appeared to implicate him in a
vast kickbacks-for-contracts scheme. Another former senior Socialist and close
Sánchez ally, José Luis Ábalos, who had been transport minister, had already
been implicated, although he insists he became unwittingly involved in the
alleged scheme. Both have been forced to leave the party; Cerdán is in
preventive custody.
Meanwhile, a judge has been investigating Sánchez’s wife, Begoña Gómez, for
alleged business irregularities, and his brother, David, is expected to go on
trial for charges that include influence peddling. Attorney General Álvaro
García Ortiz is due to face trial for revealing confidential information. All
deny any wrongdoing.
Sánchez praised pro-Palestinian protesters who repeatedly disrupted the Vuelta a
España cycling race over the involvement of an Israeli team. | Dario
Belingheri/Getty Images
The government has cast the cases implicating Sánchez’s family members and
García Ortiz as politically motivated. However, the scandals have still
dominated the political agenda, giving the impression that the prime minister
could fall at any moment.
But now the focus has switched — to Gaza.
With 82 percent of Spaniards deeming Israel’s actions in Gaza to be genocide,
according to the Royal Elcano Institute, a bold stance on the issue makes
political sense for the government.
Orriols says the Palestinian question has traditionally been a banner issue for
those to the left of Sánchez’s own Socialist Workers’ Party (PSOE), such as
Podemos and coalition partner Sumar.
“Pedro Sánchez is squeezing his rivals to his left. It’s something he’s been
doing for years in a very efficient way — poaching the rhetoric or battles that
previously belonged to other parties,” he said.
“This can tighten the connection to his own voter base, while stealing electoral
space from Sumar and Podemos. It could help the PSOE to cushion the damage
caused by corruption and political inaction.”
Israel responded by barring two of Sánchez’s ministers from entering the country
while labelling the Spanish government antisemitic. | Burak Akbulut/Anadolu via
Getty Images
The government’s dispute with Israel has also left the opposition looking
flat-footed.
The leader of the conservative People’s Party (PP), Alberto Núñez Feijóo, aware
that Spain’s right is traditionally more sympathetic to Israel than the left,
has refused to use the word “genocide.”
However, with even King Felipe denouncing an “unbearable humanitarian crisis” in
Gaza, the opposition leader has been forced to shift his position closer to that
of Sánchez and to criticize Israel’s “massacre of civilians,” while denouncing
the prime minister for using the conflict in the Middle East as a smokescreen.
“You don’t defend any noble cause, you just want to cover up your own
disgraces,” Feijóo told Sánchez in a parliamentary debate.
Others in the PP have taken a more radical line. Isabel Díaz Ayuso, the hardline
president of the Madrid region who is seen as a potential threat to Feijóo for
the party leadership, has made a point of boldly supporting Israel.
She had her photograph taken with the Israel-Premier Tech cycling team at the
center of the Vuelta turmoil, and her administration has reportedly attempted to
pressure schools not to hang Palestinian flags.
As long as Gaza remains headline news in Spain, both Ayuso and Sánchez are
likely to benefit.
Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez on Monday announced a permanent ban on the
sale of weapons and ammunition to Israel as part of a package of measures aimed
at “stopping the genocide” in Gaza.
In addition to the ban on sales from Spain, Sánchez said ships carrying fuel
destined for Israel’s armed forces will be prohibited from docking in Spanish
ports, while aircraft known to be transporting military materiel will be
forbidden from entering the country’s airspace.
Sánchez said that while Israel has a right to exist and defend itself, it does
not have the prerogative to “exterminate a defenseless people,” as he cited the
international community’s failure to address the killing of tens of thousands of
civilians in Gaza.
“Protecting your country and your society is one thing; bombing hospitals and
starving children is another,” he added, stressing Spain’s responsibility to do
whatever it can to halt “what the U.N. special rapporteur and many experts
consider a genocide.”
The package of measures announced by Sánchez forbids people who have “directly
participated in genocide, human rights violations and war crimes in the Gaza
Strip” from entering Spain. The prime minister did not clarify how the
participation would be assessed, or how those individuals would be identified.
The package also includes new restrictions on consular services offered to
Spanish citizens residing in illegal Israeli settlements in the West Bank, as
well as a total ban on products imported from occupied territories.
Sánchez has long been one of the EU’s most vocal critics of Israel’s military
assault on Gaza and last year recognized Palestinian statehood. But the
left-wing Sumar party, junior members in Sánchez’s fragile minority government,
has been pressuring the Socialist prime minister to take more aggressive action
to support Gaza.
Sumar leader and Deputy Prime Minister Yolanda Díaz on Monday celebrated the
adoption of the new measures, but urged Sánchez to go even further and withdraw
Spain’s ambassador from Tel Aviv.
In response to Sánchez’s announcement, Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon
Sa’ar accused the Spanish government of being “anti-Semitic” and using a
“hostile anti-Israeli line” to “distract attention from serious corruption
scandals.”
Sa’ar also banned Díaz and Youth Minister Cira Rego — the daughter of a
Palestinian refugee — from entering Israel, citing their “support for terrorism
and violence against Israelis.”
Spain has shelved plans to purchase F-35 fighter aircraft, Spanish newspaper El
País reported today.
Preliminary contacts for the purchase of the fifth-generation American stealth
fighters have been suspended “indefinitely” and the government will seek
European alternatives like the Eurofighter or the upcoming Future Combat Air
System, the paper reported.
“The Spanish option involves the current Eurofighter and the FCAS in the
future,” the Spanish defense ministry told POLITICO.
Spain’s decision would be a major setback for planemaker Lockheed Martin, as
Madrid issued a non-binding request for information on the F-35 in 2017.
Spain’s 2023 budget included an initial allocation of €6.25 billion to replace
navy and air force aircraft.
The Spanish navy plans to decommission its Harrier AV8B fighters by 2030 and has
expressed interest in replacing them with naval version F-35B models, already
purchased by the United States and Italy.
The air force also considered the F-35A model as a temporary solution to replace
its McDonnell Douglas F/A-18 Hornets while awaiting the FCAS.
Madrid’s move could further heat up tensions between Spain and the United
States, as Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez is a vocal critic of NATO’s new defense
spending goal of 5 percent of GDP, pushed by U.S. President Donald Trump.
This article has been updated.