THE ALTAR BOYS WHO GREW UP TOGETHER — AND TRIED TO KEEP EUROPE’S CENTER FROM
CRUMBING
The lives of Daniel Caspary and René Repasi often overlapped as they grew up. In
the European Parliament, they became political rivals — but were also united in
common cause.
By MAX GRIERA and NETTE NÖSTLINGER
in Stutensee, Germany
Photo-illustrations by Klawe Rzeczy for POLITICO
Sometimes it’s the least extraordinary places that throw up the most startling
of coincidences.
In this case, a tiny German town — nothing special: a stone’s throw from the
Rhine river, a small 18th century castle, the kind of suburban sleepiness where
boys like Daniel Caspary and René Repasi while away their teenage years cycling
to the city to party or the nearest lake to cool off — has produced rival
leading European politicians who have been key to assuring EU political
stability in a time of unprecedented fragmentation.
The way their lives have intertwined is astonishing. Caspary, now 49, and
Repasi, three years his junior, went to the same school. There, they both
organized a cabaret of political satire. They honed their skills on the student
newspaper. They were both altar boys in the same church. And they both scored
their first political victories on their town’s council. Almost since birth,
their lives have taken staggeringly parallel paths. Now, they’re on different
sides in the European Parliament.
Advertisement
Caspary is leader in the Parliament of the center-right Christian Democratic
Union (CDU) and its Bavarian sister party, the Christian Social Union (CSU), the
largest faction in the European People’s Party. Repasi is the equivalent for the
center-left Social Democratic Party (SPD), the third-largest national delegation
in the Socialists and Democrats group. The EPP and the S&D are the two biggest
Parliament groups and for decades have between them held a grip on EU power.
Despite the rivalry between their umbrella political families, with antagonism
only worsening since the 2024 EU elections, the two men have cemented their
reputation as the backchannels between the two sides, attempting to safeguard
what in EU circles is known as the “grand coalition” between center right and
center left.
That’s significant because the Parliament is fractured like never before. Aping
a trend seen across western democracies, the middle ground is crumbling.
Politicians like Caspary and Repasi represent the old ways of doing things ―
political opponents, yes, but ready to put aside their differences so their two
sides can work together to face down the extremes. Increasingly, that’s no
longer a given in the European Parliament. That was evident when the EPP,
earlier this month, abandoned its traditional centrist allies and pressed ahead
with the support of far-right groups to approve cuts to green rules.
Daniel Caspary, the charismatic old-school conservative deeply rooted in his
community, in his class photo from the year he graduated. | Stutensee’s Thomas
Mann-Gymnasium 1993-1994 annuary
René Repasi, the cosmopolitan and slick social democrat with an impressive track
record in academia, in his class photo from the year before he graduated. |
Stutensee’s Thomas Mann-Gymnasium 1993-1994 annuary
A good relationship between the pair has been particularly useful because the
leaders of the two pan-European groups rarely conceal their mutual dislike and
are increasingly finding it tough to reach compromise positions on new laws,
such as on green rules for business or on controlling migration.
“Of course we have many differences politically, but it’s good if you can talk,”
Caspary told POLITICO. “We’ve known each other for ages … We know that we can
trust each other.”
“He was always a sort of leading figure,” Repasi said, remembering their shared
childhoods in Stutensee. I “looked up to him.”
Advertisement
While their paths overlapped, they could barely be more different personally and
politically. Caspary is the charismatic old-school conservative deeply rooted in
his community, pressing the flesh at local events and using the language of the
person in the street. He still lives in the area. Repasi, by contrast, is the
cosmopolitan ― the slick social democrat with an impressive track record in
academia, a man of scholarly rhetoric who moved away from Germany completely.
“What Repasi lacks,” said Mathias Zurawski, a journalist who attended the same
school, “Caspary offers. And vice versa.”
ALTAR BOYS
Stutensee’s discreet Catholic St. Josef Church is in the town’s backstreets. The
garden surrounding it boasts abundant fruit trees. Posters advertise meetings of
the scout group. It’s humble in comparison to the more spectacular Protestant
church on the main street. It’s here where the Caspary and Repasi families
worshipped. And it’s where the two boys built trust in each other.
“We met for the first time in the youth groups of the Catholic church,” Caspary
said. “We talked about this. I think this stands for some values. We always try
to be honest.”
Those early religious experiences play a big role in Caspary’s life today, said
Ansgar Mayr, a regional CDU politician who has known him since he made his first
steps in politics.
Stutensee’s St Josef Catholic Church, where Caspary and Repasi used to serve as
altar boys. | Max Griera/POLITICO
“He was greatly influenced by his time in the Catholic Church and also his time
with the Scouts, who are Catholic Scouts,” Mayr said. “His circle of friends,
outside the political bubble, comes very much from the Catholic Church and
parish youth groups.”
The pair served as altar boys, assisting the priest at Mass and kneeling as part
of the liturgy. On Christmas, they sang carols around town.
The Social Democrat Repasi’s Catholicism has lapsed somewhat, but despite being
“one of those guys who go to church only at Christmas,” he said Christian values
serve as guidance for his daily life and political career.
CHAOS AND REVOLUTION
The pair’s paths crossed again as teenagers in high school. The Thomas-Mann
Gymnasium is just a stone’s throw from the church. It’s seen better days and is
due to be renovated next year. For now, it still looks as it did in the 1990s.
It’s easy to imagine Caspary and Repasi here. The lockers they’d have used line
the corridors and the classrooms are plain, aside from the vintage orange
cubical washbasins.
In those years, they both dived into extracurricular activities. Caspary founded
an annual political cabaret show. At 18, he handed the organizing baton to
Repasi, who suddenly found himself facing the daunting task, he said, of raising
money to cover costs.
“If the whole thing was a success, [that] was due to the fact that he [Caspary]
handed it over, and we did the transition period together,” said Repasi.
Advertisement
The boys’ school yearbooks portray two kids destined for greater things.
Alongside a photo of Caspary humorously dressed as a medic, his classmates
described him as “source of the most creative interjections (‘yes, but…’) that
elicit a wide range of reactions from teachers, ranging from amusement to
annoyance.” It’s “hard to believe,” the entry said, “that this chaotic person
will one day take on a leading role as a conservative politician.”
Repasi’s friends saw him as a revolutionary. His portrait shows him wearing a
Soviet hat. “Discussions with him often turn into fights,” his schoolmates said.
“But no one else is as good at arguing objectively.”
The boys also bumped into each other on the school’s newspaper, Pepperoni.
Caspary was already acting as a sporadic school reporter, when Repasi — a couple
of years later — became editor in chief. The boys weren’t scared of hitting the
establishment where it hurt. Pepperoni signified “something that stings” so was
“a means to express criticism,” said former teacher Sabine Graf, who taught
French and German at the school at the time.
Yearbook of Daniel Caspary, featuring a photo of Thomas Mann blended with Albert
Einstein’s famous tongue picture, symbolizing science. | 50 years anniversary
book, Thomas Mann Gymnasium 1974-2024
Covers of the Pepperoni school magazine, which both Caspary and Repasi
contributed to. | 50 years anniversary book, Thomas Mann Gymnasium 1974-2024
Yearbook of René Repasi, featuring a pig with a black flag, symbolizing social
class revolution and anarchism. | 50 years anniversary book, Thomas Mann
Gymnasium 1974-2024
Those shared experiences form the basis of the two men’s relationship in the
Parliament today.
“You can always say you can trust me,” Repasi said. “But actually you can only
do so if you have experienced it. And I experienced it in my past that I can
trust him and that I can rely on him.”
VOTERS’ CRITICISM
These days, Stutensee isn’t immune to the political winds that blow across the
whole of Europe. With populism, of right and left, on the rise, centrist
politicians who broadly prefer to focus on points of agreement rather than
division aren’t in vogue.
The Alternative for Germany (AfD) came in second in Germany’s national election
earlier this year ― the best showing for a far-right party since the Nazi rise
to power. The AfD isn’t represented on the city council here, but locals
acknowledge there’s a desire to kick the establishment. An establishment
symbolized by men like Caspary and Repasi.
Despite their deep roots in the town, many reject the idea they’re local heroes.
“They show up at some celebratory events around town with their family a couple
of times a year, but you don’t hear from them afterwards,” said a 37-year-old
bartender at the smoke-filled bar in town, who gives his name only as Dominik. A
handful of people at the bar hear his remarks and nod.
Dominik also went to Thomas-Mann Gymnasium. He knew Caspary’s brother. But he
insisted neither politician can be trusted. They’re not “looking out for the
interests of the people,” he said.
But early on in their careers, the two politicians made some tangible changes
for locals. When they were both on their school’s student council, Caspary
campaigned for a night bus line between Stutensee and the city of Karlsruhe,
10km away. In some ways, he succeeded, advancing a cause that led to the
construction of a durable tram connection built years later.
“During this campaign, I realized that if you start engaging with the town
representatives, like the mayor, like the city council members, then you can
change things,” Caspary said.
Advertisement
Repasi’s political awakening came when the regional government tried to cut by a
year the time that students attended high school to align practices with other
European countries. The school’s leadership wanted to participate in the pilot,
despite most students being opposed.
“I found it total nonsense,” Repasi said. “I was mobilizing the school kids to
come to this meeting of the municipal council, and I think for the first time
ever it was totally full.”
The students cheered loudly when their arguments, compiled by Repasi, were
presented to the mayor. The council ultimately rejected the plan. If the bus
line was Caspary’s first political victory, this was Repasi’s.
MR. STUTENSEE VS. MR. EUROPE
Eventually, they drifted apart.
These days, Caspary’s image is one of a politician still deeply rooted to his
home, who found his way to Brussels by chance. People close to him describe him
as a family man, raising his five children just a few kilometers from where he
grew up.
Repasi, in contrast, is seen as a professor-turned-politician, someone with a
strong passion for European affairs who deliberately chose to build his life
abroad.
Classroom of Thomas Mann Gymnasium, intact since Caspary and Repasi studied in
it. | Max Griera/POLITICO
For Repasi, who was raised by a German mother and Hungarian father,
“cosmopolitanism runs through his life,” said Graf, the schoolteacher. She and
another former teacher both recalled his in-depth study on the Yugoslav Wars. He
became a professor of European law in Geneva and Rotterdam, where he raised two
sons with his Polish wife.
Caspary was elected to the European Parliament almost by accident in 2004, at
28, because of the CDU’s exceptionally strong showing.
“My plan was to become the chairperson of the group in my city council,” he
said.
Advertisement
For Repasi, on the other hand, ending up working in an EU institution was his
dream, according to colleagues. He even dabbled with joining Caspary in the CDU.
But in his village, the party didn’t feel very welcoming, he said. “I’m
Western-looking enough not to have any discrimination experiences like Turkish
people, but my strange family name was strange enough in my village,” he said.
Repasi’s road to the Parliament was bumpier than Caspary’s. He ran in three
elections but never made it, ultimately joining when another SPD member gave up
her mandate in 2022.
TOGETHER IN BRUSSELS ― AND THEN APART AGAIN
Reuniting in the European Parliament was almost like a homecoming for Repasi.
Caspary presented him with a basket of delicacies from the region around
Stutensee.
Repasi’s rise since then has been rapid. He became the head of the SPD faction
in the S&D only two years after his arrival. And in that time, they’ve put their
friendship to good use.
Cordial catchups soon turned into high-level political negotiations. They were
suddenly in charge of leading the biggest German parties in the Parliament and
had to overcome the increasing estrangement between their group leaders, Manfred
Weber, the head of the EPP group, and Iratxe García, the S&D chair.
Caspary was elected to the European Parliament almost by accident in 2004
because of the CDU’s exceptionally strong showing. | Michael Kappeler/picture
alliance via Getty Images
For Repasi, ending up working in an EU institution was his dream. | Marijan
Murat/picture alliance via Getty Images
That’s why they have been in constant dialogue, “to bring together political
lines,” Caspary said.
“We do speak about conflicts that are arising,” Repasi said. “Whether we can
totally solve them is a different question.”
Other MEPs say the good relationship between the German conservatives and
Socialists has proved critical.
“The stability of the mandate” ― European Commission President Ursula von der
Leyen’s loose coalition of centrist parties ― “is at stake, and what can help
cement a stronger cooperation is the link between the CDU and SPD,” said Javi
López, a Spanish S&D lawmaker and Parliament vice-president.
But nothing lasts forever and the double act is about to split once more. In
October, the German government nominated Caspary to be its representative at the
European Court of Auditors, in Luxembourg.
Advertisement
On Thursday he is expected to be confirmed by the Parliament. That will leave a
gap, according to his colleagues.
“Over the years, he has been a steady and unifying presence, bringing together a
team of highly diverse personalities,” said Niclas Herbst, chair of the
Parliament budgetary control committee, and one of the names floated to succeed
Caspary. “He is, in the best sense, a true generalist — someone who can swiftly
and thoroughly grasp complex political issues … I know there is great
anticipation in Luxembourg for his arrival.”
When Caspary departs, Repasi will have to find himself another opposite number
to build up a trusting relationship. But it remains to be seen whether the
fraying ties between center right and center left can retain at least one strong
thread.
While that won’t be impossible, it certainly won’t come as easy as a
relationship forged in little Stutensee. Out of experiences in church, student
politics and the school newspaper, the foundations held up well.
Tag - Cycling
Slovak police on Thursday said the new amendment to a traffic law that sets a
maximum permitted speed on sidewalks in urban areas does not apply to
pedestrians.
Several local and international media, including POLITICO, earlier reported that
the law — which sets a limit of 6 kilometers per hour — will apply to
pedestrians as well.
“I must clarify that this is not true,” police Vice President Rastislav
Polakovič told Slovak media. “The rule is intended for people using roller
skates, scooters, skateboards, skis, or similar sports equipment, as well as
cyclists up to 10 years old, including their escorts. The measurements should
focus on these groups.”
The initial announcement sparked a wave of amusement and confusion on social
media, with some internet users wondering whether running to catch a bus could
get them fined. The legislation that was updated by the new amendment applies to
various sidewalk users.
The measure, which will enter into force on Jan. 1, 2026, was introduced to
avoid collisions on the sidewalks.
“The main goal is to increase safety on sidewalks in light of the increasing
number of collisions with scooter riders,” said the author of the amendment,
Ľubomír Vážny of the leftist-populist Smer party of Prime Minister Robert Fico,
which is part of the ruling coalition.
The change drew backlash from the opposition, NGOs and political scientists.
“In the Czech Republic, this issue is addressed by banning scooters and e-bikes
on sidewalks, while the Slovak approach has led to a rather bizarre piece of
legislation,” political scientist Lubomír Kopeček at the Masaryk University in
Brno told POLITICO.
The cyclist advocacy group Cyklokoalícia (Cycling Coalition) said the
legislation is problematic because it pushes children under the age of 10 — who
are now allowed to cycle on pavements — into the road.
You can only walk 6 kilometers per hour if you want to follow the law in
Slovakia.
The Slovak parliament Tuesday afternoon adopted an amendment to the traffic law
that sets a maximum permitted speed on sidewalks in urban areas at 6 kph.
The limit applies to pedestrians, cyclists, skaters, and scooter and e-scooter
riders — all of who are allowed on sidewalks — and aims to avoid frequent
collisions.
“The main goal is to increase safety on sidewalks in light of the increasing
number of collisions with scooter riders,” said the author of the amendment,
Ľubomír Vážny of the leftist-populist Smer party of Prime Minister Robert Fico,
which is part of the ruling coalition.
The amendment will be useful in proving violations, the lawmaker said,
“especially in cases where it’s necessary to objectively determine whether they
were moving faster than what’s considered an appropriate speed in areas meant
primarily for pedestrians.”
Although the law will come into force Jan. 1, 2026, proponents haven’t publicly
spelled out how they plan to enforce it.
The average walking speed typically ranges between 4 to 5 kph. However, the
British Heart Foundation reports that a pace of 6.4 kilometers per hour is
considered moderate for someone with excellent fitness.
The opposition criticized the change, and even the Slovak Interior Ministry said
it would be more appropriate to prohibit e-scooters from the sidewalks than
impose a general speed limit.
Martin Pekár of the opposition liberal party Progressive Slovakia said
pedestrians face danger from cars, not cyclists or scooters, and that the
amendment penalizes sustainable transport.
“If we want fewer collisions, we need more safe bike lanes, not absurd limits
that are physically impossible to follow,” Pekár said. “At the mentioned speed,
a cyclist can hardly keep their balance,” he added.
The amendment has sparked a wave of amusement on social media, with some
wondering whether running to catch a bus could get them fined.
RINGASKIDDY, Ireland — When Pfizer started manufacturing its anti-impotence drug
Viagra in southwestern Ireland, locals experienced a spike in sexual arousal,
five-legged rabbits proliferated, and visitors took U-turns back to their
spouses after fumes from its local plant drifted in through their car windows.
That’s according to local legend, at least.
These stories “transited through the local pub,” said Pat Hennessy, a long-term
resident of Shanbally, just up the road from the coastal village of Ringaskiddy.
“There was a girl there and she said: ‘One whiff and they’re stiff.’”
The impact of Big Pharma on the area, however, goes far beyond amusing
anecdotes: Its arrival in the 1970s turned a sleepy fishing village into an
industrial powerhouse and turbocharged economic growth in County Cork. But
today, the industry — and the region that depends on it — are in the eye of U.S.
President Donald Trump’s tariff storm.
As he drives to slash the massive U.S. trade deficit, Trump says he is
determined to reshore the production of weight-loss drugs, cancer treatments and
other pharmaceuticals. He has threatened to eventually slam tariffs as high as
250 percent on the sector.
Ireland, Trump says, “took our pharmaceutical companies away” with its tax
policies: Of the $213 billion of medicines the U.S. imports, the largest share
comes from Ireland, a global leader in the production of expensive brand-name
medicines. Dublin’s liberal tax regime has exerted an irresistible pull on U.S.
Big Pharma for decades.
Locals find only limited solace in a deal struck in July between the European
Union and the White House which — at least on paper — caps U.S. tariffs on
pharmaceutical imports from the EU at 15 percent and exempts generic medicines.
Ireland, as one of the EU’s most open economies, is particularly vulnerable to
the tariffs, and uncertainty persists over Trump’s next moves and the damage
they could inflict.
“It’s still like an axe hanging over us,” said David Collins, the
fifth-generation owner of a family-run store in Carrigaline, a commuter town 20
minutes by bike from Ringaskiddy. “It’s a constant threat.”
The area is home to seven of the 10 largest pharma companies worldwide. More
than 11,000 people in County Cork work in the industry — with tens of thousands
more in ancillary jobs.
Ringaskiddy alone hosts Pfizer and Johnson & Johnson, Sterling Pharma Solutions
producing for Novartis, as well as smaller firms such as Recordati, BioMarin and
Hovione. In addition to Viagra’s active ingredient, critical components of
cardiology, immunology and oncology medications are made here.
PITCH AND PUTT
When Pfizer arrived in 1969, its workers spent their lunch breaks building a
course to play pitch and putt — a scaled-down version of golf — for the local
community, recalled Michael Goably, a pensioner, while enjoying his morning
coffee at the clubhouse of Raffeen Creek Golf Club, nestled on the lush shores
of Cork harbour.
As the name suggests, a nine-hole golf course, also built on land owned by
Pfizer, now complements the pitch and putt. It’s just one example of how the
area has benefited from big pharma: Ask the locals, and they’ll tell you the
industry’s contribution far outweighs the side effects, such as commuter traffic
and environmental pollution.
“I couldn’t say a bad word,” said Ray Keohane, another golfer taking a break on
a bench between rounds.
The town of Carrigaline, once an agricultural village, now counts 20,000
residents, as well as a hotel, several supermarkets and a lively shopping
street.
“When I was a child growing up in Carrigaline, there was one main industry, and
it was called Carrigaline Pottery … there wasn’t a family in the area of
Carrigaline that didn’t at least have one person working in the pottery,” said
Collins, the supermarket owner.
“Roll on 50 years later, that’s been replaced by the pharmaceutical
industries.”
CELTIC TIGER
The arrival of multinational corporations softened the impact of the closure of
manufacturing sites by carmaker Ford and Dunlop, a tyre company, in the 1980s.
“Ireland as a country wasn’t doing well, but Cork was a particularly black spot
then,” said John O’Brien, a lecturer in finance at University College Cork. “The
combination of pharmaceuticals and IT … together really have brought up the
city,” he added, referring to Ireland’s second-largest city Cork, which hosts
the EU headquarters of tech giant Apple.
Nationally, the success in the pharma sector helped drive economic growth in
Ireland’s “Celtic Tiger” era from the 1990s to the late 2000s. That’s thanks to
large-scale foreign investment — especially from the U.S. — low corporate taxes,
a skilled English-speaking workforce and EU membership.
According to Louis Brennan, an emeritus professor at Trinity College Dublin,
pharma’s contribution was threefold: It created high-value and high-paying jobs,
led to the development of an ecosystem of suppliers and subcontractors, and
generated government revenues.
Cork has also established itself as a hub for higher education in pharma-related
fields.
TARIFF GAMES
Since Trump’s return to the White House, that engine of the Irish economy finds
itself under (verbal) attack, exposing just how much Irish success hinges on the
country’s capacity to remain the go-to location for U.S. firms, which beyond
welcoming tax benefits have also long shifted their profits and patents there.
“We want pharmaceuticals made in our country,” Trump told CNBC in August.
As part of his vow to slash drug prices and bring manufacturing back to the
U.S., Trump in April opened a so-called Section 232 investigation into the
pharmaceutical sector to probe the impact of imports on national security and
impose tariffs if needed.
Analysts estimate that Trump is unlikely to impose a tariff as high as the
threatened 200 or 250 percent. However, a first “lower tariff” — no higher
than 15 percent, provided Trump does indeed stick to the terms of the EU-U.S.
agreement — could yet be followed by a heavily disruptive tariff of around 50
percent after a year or two.
The message isn’t lost on big pharma: Giants such as Eli Lilly and Johnson &
Johnson have this year announced new investments in the U.S. Yet experts warn
Trump’s tariff policy risks driving up drug prices and leading to shortages,
rather than spurring large-scale relocation.
While the 15 percent tariff cap foreseen by the EU-U.S. deal offers the industry
a reprieve, companies need to make tricky calculations, warned Dan O’Brien,
chief economist at the Institute of International and European Affairs, an Irish
think tank.
“For those products that are uniquely made in Ireland there is at least some
element of a buffer: It’ll take a few years for production to move out of
Ireland, in a worst-case scenario,” he said. For products also made elsewhere,
it will be easier to shift production and “could happen more quickly,” he
added.
RISKY BUSINESS
For now, those scenarios remain hypothetical — but the unpredictability is
already leaving its mark.
As companies rushed to export their goods, Irish pharma exports to the U.S.
surged by nearly 50 percent in the first five months of this year. “Geopolitical
concerns” now rank among the top three threats to business in the Cork Chamber
of Commerce’s last survey of its members.
Companies are mostly keeping quiet. Pfizer and Johnson & Johnson declined to
comment for this story, whereas Sterling Pharma Solutions, BioMarin, Recordati
and Hovione did not respond to requests for comment. Novartis, which is supplied
by Sterling Pharma Solutions, warned that “the introduction of tariffs risks
creating additional barriers that could further delay access to life-saving
treatments.”
Giants such as Eli Lilly and Johnson & Johnson have this year announced new
investments in the U.S. | Cristina Arias/Getty Images
Reacting to the deal between the EU-U.S. deal, the Irish Pharmaceutical
Healthcare Association warned that “tariffs on medicines would be a substantial
new cost where there was none before and a drag on investment, jobs and
innovation.”
A worker at a pharma plant in the area, granted anonymity to protect their job
security, told POLITICO output had slowed in the last couple of months as the
company waited to regain planning certainty.
Similarly, Dan Boyle, a Green Party councillor for Cork and the city’s former
mayor, said companies told him that “our hope was that we would have announced
future investment for 2030, and that’s being sat on, until we know what the
situation is going to be.”
UNDER PRESSURE
Local, national and European politicians are acutely aware of just how much is
at stake.
Séamus McGrath, a Dáil deputy for the Cork South-Central constituency, called
for a “continuous process of renegotiation and engagement” with Washington.
“We need to renew our pitch and renew our attraction as a country for foreign
direct investment,” said McGrath, sitting in the lobby of the Carrigaline Court
Hotel, the town’s only hotel. “You cannot sit back.”
The politician with the co-governing centrist Fianna Fáil party entertains
strong ties with Brussels, not least thanks to his brother, EU Justice
Commissioner Michael McGrath.
In the EU capital, lawmakers from the region are urging the EU to boost the
bloc’s competitiveness. Cynthia Ní Mhurchú, of the liberal Renew Europe group,
called for cutting “excessive red tape” for businesses. And Seán Kelly, an MEP
with the centre-right European People’s Party, welcomed the European
Commission’s plans to secure access to new markets through trade deals.
After all, for locals back on the Irish coast, power politics determine no less
than their personal future.
“They say they [the big companies] will go away,” said Amy Lyons, a bartender at
Ringaskiddy’s only pub, The Ferry Boat Inn.
“I’m doing a biopharma course in college. So, imagine I get my degree, and they
are gone,” she added as she drew pints for the regulars, who were discussing a
new road being built to ease road congestion — caused by commuter traffic to the
pharma plants.
Graphics by Hanne Cokelaere.
PARIS — In France, getting rid of governments is now about as commonplace as
complaining about them.
François Bayrou is bracing to become the latest prime minister to get the chop
on Monday ― primarily because of discontent over his spending plans for next
year ― leaving President Emmanuel Macron on the hunt for a fifth PM in less than
two years.
The political crisis could have ramifications far beyond the halls of power in
Paris if lawmakers can’t figure out how to rein in runaway public spending and a
massive budget deficit.
Here’s everything you need to know about the drama ahead:
HE’S DEFINITELY GOING, RIGHT?
Yes, it’s pretty much nailed on that Bayrou will fall. Anything else would need
a last-minute U-turn from a big chunk of opposition lawmakers, and that would be
a massive shock.
His fate seem sealed in the hours after he unveiled his plan for a confidence
vote late last month, when leaders from the far-left France Unbowed, far-right
National Rally and center-left Socialist Party all announced they would vote to
bring down the government.
Neither Bayrou’s PR blitz nor his meetings with political leaders last week
appear to have moved the needle.
SO WHAT’S HAPPENING MONDAY?
Bayrou is delivering what’s known as a d´eclaration de politique générale
(general policy statement), a speech traditionally given at the outset of a
prime minister’s tenure to lay out an incoming government’s platform and
priorities. (It’s a bit like a state of the union.) The longtime centrist is
using this one to make the case for his unpopular 2026 budget.
Prime ministers often follow their addresses with a confidence vote to ensure
support for their agendas, though they aren’t constitutionally obliged to do so.
Bayrou didn’t hold a vote after his January DPG, nor did any of his predecessors
during Macron’s second term.
Christophe Petit Tesson/EPA
This time, he will.
Bayrou has tried to frame the vote as a referendum on the need for drastic
action to balance the books and has quibbled with the French media’s framing of
Monday’s drama as a confidence vote or censure. But in practice, that’s what it
is.
HOW WILL THE DAY UNFOLD?
Bayrou’s speech will begin at 3 p.m. in the National Assembly in Paris, France’s
more-powerful lower house of parliament. Representatives from each political
party will follow, with each of their speaking times determined by how many
seats they have. Then the prime minister will have the opportunity to deliver
closing remarks.
Voting should take place around 7 p.m. or 8 p.m. and should last about 30
minutes, after which the president of the National Assembly will announce the
results.
Macron’s office has not yet said whether he will speak following the vote. When
ex-Prime Minister Michel Barnier was toppled in December, Macron waited 24 hours
to deliver a primetime address.
HOW DID WE GET HERE?
Let’s rewind to June 9, 2024, when the far-right National Rally scored a huge
win in the European election. Macron responded by dissolving parliament, a
massive bet that backfired in spectacular fashion.
In the ensuing vote, an alliance of left-leaning political parties won more
seats than any other political force, but fell short of an absolute majority.
After nearly two months without a proper government, Macron’s centrists and the
center-right conservatives agreed to form a minority coalition led by former
Brexit negotiator Barnier.
Barnier lasted three months, taken down in December over his plan to trim the
2025 budget to help rein in runaway public spending.
Macron replaced Barnier with Bayrou, who in July presented a plan to squeeze
next year’s budget by €43.8 billion to get the budget deficit down from a
projected 5.4 percent of gross domestic product this year to 4.6 percent of GDP
in 2026.
Opposition lawmakers howled in fury at the plan, which included axing two public
holidays.
In late August, as the French started to trickle back from their summer
vacations, Bayrou stunned the country by announcing that he would hold a
confidence vote on his spending plans before what were expected to be tense
negotiations.
SHOULD I CARE?
Yes, because the ensuing crisis in the eurozone’s second-biggest economy could
drag the entire bloc into a debt-fueled financial crisis, according to Bayrou.
France was able to stave off an economic catastrophe during the pandemic and
when energy prices shot up at the outset of the full-scale war in Ukraine, in
part thanks to massive public spending. Finding a consensus on reining in
expenditures has proven difficult, and lawmakers are loath to tighten their
belts as aggressively as Bayrou wants.
His plan would bring France’s budget deficit down from a projected 5.6 percent
of GDP this year to 4.6 percent in 2026. The ultimate goal is to bring that
figure down to 3 percent, as required by EU rules, by 2029.
Financial institutions and rating agencies have repeatedly warned of
consequences should France fail to act, some of which are no longer
hypothetical.
Borrowing costs are rising, with the yield on France’s benchmark 10-year bonds ―
a useful indicator of faith in a country’s finances ― drifting away from
historically safe Germany’s yields and toward those of Italy, a country long
synonymous with reckless spending and unsustainable debt.
Getting the French to tighten their belts has so far proven to be Mission
Impossible, but the situation is not yet so dire that it’s time to call in the
IMF.
Bayrou, however, is betting his political future that history will prove him
right.
Elisabeth Braw is a senior fellow at the Atlantic Council, the author of the
award-winning “Goodbye Globalization” and a regular columnist for POLITICO.
For many locals the world over, this summer — just like every summer and,
indeed, every month — tourism brings misery rather than enjoyment. In Barcelona,
locals fed up with overtourism took to the streets in protest. In Genoa, Lisbon
and the Canary Islands, they did the same. And in Venice, locals were enraged
their city had to play backdrop to tech billionaire Jeff Bezos’s wedding party.
Copenhagen, however, has turned the tourism curse on its head, inviting visitors
to do good deeds for the city and be rewarded for it in return. And it’s time
other cities got similarly creative.
“During 2024, the Spanish tourism sector experienced its best year since 2019.
Its contribution to GDP rose by almost 8% to €248.7 billion, or 15.6% of the
economy. It also employed 3 million people, nearly 14% of the country’s total
jobs,” the World Travel & Tourism Council reported in May. For many Spaniards,
though, this hardly feels like good news. In fact, it’s quite the opposite. To
them — and to locals in many other cities tourists like to visit — what it
actually means is overcrowding, lack of housing and constant littering.
It’s a cursed bargain, tourism: It brings in cash and jobs, but the more tourism
you get, the more locals’ discomfort turns to misery. These days, even the
trails leading up to the Himalayas are tainted by litter — and don’t even
mention Instagram tourism.
But tourism doesn’t need to be this destructive. Switzerland, for example, has
begun giving rail discounts to those who book a stay at sustainable hotels, and
it charges anyone visiting the Lake Brienz pier, which was made famous by the
Korean drama “Crash Landing on You,” 5 Swiss francs. The proceeds are then
invested in local infrastructure.
Copenhagen’s approach is even more innovative. Last year, the Danish capital
launched CopenPay, a scheme that invites tourists to do good deeds for the city
— and get rewarded. “All you need to do is, for instance, bike instead of drive,
help maintain the city, work in an urban garden or take the train to Copenhagen
instead of flying, stay longer at the destination,” CopenPay explains.
The initiative was launched as a four-week pilot program last year, and this
summer it expanded to nine weeks, with 100 attractions participating — a
fourfold increase.
For instance, as part of CopenPay, there are currently 15 different
opportunities to clean up litter across the city, one of which is to “Clean the
harbor with GreenKayak and enjoy a free non-alcoholic drink and rye bar with
your Smørrebrød purchase at Hallernes Smørrebrød.”
While I can’t speak for everyone, to me, cleaning the harbor in central
Copenhagen by kayak certainly sounds like an exciting undertaking I’d do for
free — though I’d also happily claim the beverage. And if that doesn’t quite
strike your fancy, you can help clean the harbor by self-sailing boat too.
And picking up litter is just the beginning. If you bike or use public transport
to get to the National Museum, you get a free ice cream with your entry ticket.
If you arrive in Copenhagen by train or electric car, you get similarly
rewarded. There are free bike rentals, free yoga sessions, free guided tours,
all waiting to be claimed. Visitors arriving by train from abroad can even get
free surplus meals at Copenhagen Central Station.
There are free bike rentals, free yoga sessions, free guided tours, all waiting
to be claimed. | Mads Claus Rasmussen/EPA
You get the idea: Be a good citizen while you visit, and good things will come
your way. And hopefully the impact of CopenPay — and other similar initiatives
currently in the works — won’t stop there. Imagine if participants start
thinking differently about their role as tourists. Once you take part in city
maintenance as a temporary sanitation worker, perhaps you start viewing your
surroundings less as an Instagram commodity and more as a local community worth
protecting.
Imagine what such participatory schemes could do for other tourist destinations,
especially those most affected by throngs of oblivious visitors. I’ve long
wondered how Romans can be so tolerant of the throngs that crowd their beautiful
piazzas and narrow streets. How could the local government convince visitors to
stop congregating and littering in front of Fontana di Trevi? Perhaps they
should introduce a scheme inviting tourists to pick up litter and intimately get
to know a street or two, or perhaps sweep the floor of one of the city’s many
stunning churches, or tend to part of a graveyard. It would certainly be a
memory to tell one’s friends about.
Yes, there are reasons why such initiatives may not work. Dishonest tourists
will claim to have done a good deed when they haven’t — CopenPay, for example,
operates on an honor system. But tourism isn’t just a burden to locals, it’s a
burden on our planet. It emits some 8 percent of the world’s carbon dioxide and
is 20 percent more carbon-intensive than the average for the global economy.
Offering tourists the opportunity to pick up litter as they explore local
waterways may not work for every town and city, but each destination can easily
come up with its own innovative ideas. Just imagine cities full of visitors who
bring a helping hand as well as their cash. That ought to be tourism we can live
with.
Helsinki hasn’t registered a single traffic-related fatality in the past year,
municipal officials revealed this week.
Although road deaths are on the decline across the EU, with a 3 percent decrease
in 2024, accidents with tragic outcomes are still commonplace in metropolitan
areas. To go a full year without one is a remarkable feat for most cities — let
alone a European capital.
In 2023, 7,807 Europeans lost their lives in traffic accidents in EU cities.
Fifty-five people died in traffic accidents in Berlin last year, and nine
individuals lost their lives in collisions in the Brussels region over the past
12 months.
While Helsinki is among the smallest EU capitals, with a little under 690,000
residents, some 1.5 million people live in and commute throughout the
metropolitan area.
Roni Utriainen, a traffic engineer with the city’s Urban Environment Division,
told the Finnish press that the achievement was attributable to “a lot of
factors … but speed limits are one of the most important.”
Citing data that shows the risk of pedestrian fatality is cut in half by
reducing a car’s speed of impact from 40 to 30 kilometers per hour, city
officials imposed the lower limit in most of Helsinki’s residential areas and
city center in 2021.
The limits were enforced with 70 new speed cameras and a policing strategy based
on the national “Vision Zero” policy, with the goal of achieving zero traffic
injuries or deaths. Data collected by Liikenneturva, Finland’s traffic safety
entity, shows Helsinki’s traffic fatalities have been declining ever since.
EUROPEAN MODEL
Helsinki’s authorities have spent the past five years trying to replicate the
miracle they first achieved in 2019, when no pedestrians or cyclists were killed
in automotive collisions.
Utriainen stressed the mission’s success is based on data-driven, long-term
mobility policies and urban development strategies that have transformed the
once car-centric capital. In many parts of the city, roads have been narrowed
and trees have been planted with the deliberate goal of making drivers
uncomfortable — the rationale being that complex urban landscapes force drivers
to move more cautiously through populated areas.
The city has also invested in new pedestrian and cycling infrastructure,
including a comprehensive network of cycling paths that span over 1,500
kilometers. It has boosted its public transportation network with decarbonized
and self-driving buses, and received European Investment Bank funding for a new
tram line.
Utriainen said the upgrades helped “reduce car use and, with it, the number of
serious accidents.” And statistics show that between 2003 and 2023, the number
of traffic-related injuries in the city dropped from 727 to just 14.
Helsinki’s success is being noted in Brussels, where the European Commission is
pressing to curb road fatalities. Earlier this year, Transport Commissioner
Apostolos Tzitzikostas noted most member countries weren’t on track to meet the
EU’s 2018 goal of halving traffic-related fatalities by 2030.
Hanne Cokelaere contributed to this article.