LONDON — The U.K.’s data protection watchdog has opened a formal investigation
into Elon Musk’s companies X and xAI, over the use of personal data by the Grok
AI system to generate a flood of sexualized deepfakes.
In a statement on Tuesday, the Information Commissioner’s Office said the
“reported creation and circulation of such content raises serious concerns under
U.K. data protection law and presents a risk of significant potential harm to
the public.”
“These concerns relate to whether personal data has been processed lawfully,
fairly and transparently, and whether appropriate safeguards were built into
Grok’s design and deployment to prevent the generation of harmful manipulated
images using personal data,” it said.
The formal investigation follows an announcement last month that the ICO was
seeking urgent information from X and xAI, amid widespread reports that Grok had
been used to generate sexualized images of children and adults.
William Malcolm, executive director for regulatory risk and innovation at the
ICO, said the reports about Grok “raise deeply troubling questions about how
people’s personal data has been used.”
“Losing control of personal data in this way can cause immediate and significant
harm. This is particularly the case where children are involved,” Malcolm said.
“Where we find obligations have not been met, we will take action to protect the
public.”
While the ICO’s investigation will focus on X and xAI’s compliance with U.K.
data protection law, Malcolm said it would work closely with other regulators in
the U.K. and abroad that are also investigating the issue.
Ofcom, the U.K.’s communications regulator, opened a formal investigation into X
last month under the Online Safety Act. That investigation is ongoing, Ofcom
said on Tuesday. It is progressing “as a matter of urgency” but could take
“months,” Ofcom added, noting that it must follow a “fair process” and “it would
not be appropriate to provide a running commentary.”
Ofcom also said it is not currently investigating xAI, which provides the
standalone Grok AI tool, noting that “it can only take action on online harms
covered by the [OSA].” The act does not apply to AI tools which do not involve
searching the internet, interacting with other social media users, or generating
pornography, it said.
The U.K.’s Technology Secretary Liz Kendall has previously said she is assessing
options to address “gaps” in the OSA.
The European Commission announced its own probe into X last month, while French
authorities searched X’s offices in Paris on Tuesday as part of their own
criminal investigation into Grok, POLITICO reported.
X did not immediately respond when contacted for comment.
Tag - Technology UK
Millions of people are forming emotional bonds with artificial intelligence
chatbots — a problem that politicians need to take seriously, according to top
scientists.
The warning of a rise in AI bots designed to develop a relationship with users
comes in an assessment released Tuesday on the progress and risks of artificial
intelligence.
“AI companions have grown rapidly in popularity, with some applications reaching
tens of millions of users,” according to the assessment from dozens of experts,
mostly academics — completed for the second time under a global effort launched
by world leaders in 2023.
Specialized companion services such as Replika and Character.ai have user
numbers in the tens of millions — with users citing a variety of reasons
including fun and curiosity, as well as to alleviate loneliness, the report
says.
But people can also seek companionship from general-purpose tools such as
OpenAI’s ChatGPT, Google’s Gemini or Anthropic’s Claude.
“Even the ordinary chatbots can become companions,” said Yoshua Bengio, a
professor at the University of Montreal and lead author of the International AI
Safety report. Bengio is considered one of the world’s leading voices on AI. “In
the right context and with enough interactions between the user and the AI, a
relationship can develop,” he said.
While the assessment acknowledges that evidence regarding the psychological
effects of companions is mixed, “some studies report patterns such as increased
loneliness and reduced social interaction among frequent users,” the report
says.
The warning lands two weeks after dozens of European Parliament lawmakers
pressed the European Commission to look into the possibility of restricting
companion services under the EU’s AI law amid concerns over their impact on
mental health.
“I can see in political circles that the effect of these AI companions on
children, especially adolescents, is something that is raising a lot of eyebrows
and attention,” said Bengio.
The worries are fueled by the sycophantic nature of chatbots, which aim to be
helpful for their users and please them as much as possible.
“The AI is trying to make us, in the immediate moment, feel good, but that isn’t
always in our interest,” Bengio said. In that sense, the technology has similar
pitfalls to social media platforms, he argued.
Bengio said to expect that new regulations will be introduced to address the
phenomenon.
He pushed back, however, against the idea of introducing specific rules for AI
companions and argued that the risk should be addressed through horizontal
legislation which addresses several risks simultaneously.
The International AI Safety report lands ahead of a global summit starting Feb.
16, an annual gathering for countries to discuss governance of the technology
that this year is held in India.
Tuesday’s report lists the full series of risks that policymakers will have to
address, including AI-fueled cyberattacks, AI-generated sexually explicit
deepfakes and AI systems that provide information on how to design bioweapons.
Bengio urged governments and the European Commission to enhance their internal
AI expertise to address the long list of potential risks.
World leaders first gave a mandate for the annual assessment at the 2023 AI
Safety Summit in the United Kingdom. Some of the advisers are well-known figures
in the Brussels tech policy world, including former European Parliament lawmaker
Marietje Schaake.
SHANGHAI — As Keir Starmer arrived for the first visit by a British prime
minister to China for eight years, he stood next to a TV game show-style wheel
of fortune.
The arrow pointed at “rise high,” next to “get rich immediately” and “everything
will go smoothly.” Not one option on the wheel was negative.
Sadly for the U.K. prime minister, reality does not match the wheel — but he
gave it a good go.
After an almost decade-long British chill toward China, Starmer reveled in three
hours of talks and lunch with Chinese President Xi Jinping on Thursday, where he
called for a “more sophisticated” relationship and won effusive praise in
return. Britain boasted it had secured visa-free travel for British citizens to
China for up to 30 days and a cut in Chinese tariffs on Scotch whisky. Xi even
said the warming would help “world peace.”
His wins so far (many details of which remain vague) are only a tiny sliver of
the range of opportunities he claimed Chinese engagement could bring — and do
not even touch on the controversies, given Beijing’s record on aggressive trade
practices, human rights, espionage, cyber sabotage and transnational repression.
But the vibes on the ground are clear — Starmer is loving it, and wants to go
much further.
POLITICO picks out five takeaways from following the entourage.
1) THERE’S NO TURNING BACK NOW
Britain is now rolling inevitably toward greater engagement in a way that will
be hard to reverse.
Labour’s warming to China has been in train since the party was in opposition,
inspired by the U.S. Democrats and Australian Labor, and the lead-up to this
meeting took more than a year.
No. 10 has bought into China’s reliance on protocol and iterative engagement. Xi
is said to have been significantly warmer toward Starmer this week (their second
meeting) than the first time they met at the G20 in Rome. Officials say it takes
a long time to warm him up.
There is no doubt China’s readout of the meeting was deliberately friendlier to
Labour than the Conservatives. One person on the last leader-level visit to
China, by Conservative PM Theresa May in 2018, recalled that the meetings were
“intellectually grueling” because Xi used consecutive translation, speaking for
long periods before May could reply. This time officials say he used
simultaneous translation.
It will not end here — because Starmer can’t afford for it to. Many of the dozen
or so deals announced this week are only commitments to investigate options for
future cooperation, so Britain will need to now push them into reality, with an
array of dialogues planned in the future along with a visit by Foreign Secretary
Yvette Cooper.
As Business Secretary Peter Kyle told a Thursday night reception at the British
Embassy: “This trip is just the start.”
2) BRITAIN’S STILL ON THE EASY WINS
Deals on whisky tariffs and visa-free travel were top of the No. 10 list but —
as standalone wins without national security implications — they were the
lowest-hanging fruit.
The two sides agreed to explore whether to enter negotiations towards a
bilateral services agreement, which would make it easier for lawyers and
accountants to use their professional qualifications across the two countries.
In return, investment decisions in China were announced by firms including
AstraZeneca and Octopus Energy.
But many of the other deals are only the start of a dialogue. One U.K. official
called them “jam tomorrow deals.”
And Luke de Pulford, of the Inter-Parliamentary Alliance on China campaign
group, argued that despite Britain having a slight trade surplus in services
“it’s tiny compared to the whole.” He added: “This trip to China seems to be
based upon the notion that China is part of the solution to our economic woes.
It’s not rooted in any evidence. China hasn’t done foreign direct investment in
any serious way since 2017. It’s dropped off a cliff.”
Then there are areas — particularly wind farms — where officials are more edgy
and which weren’t discussed by Starmer and Xi. One industry figure dismissed
concerns that China could install “kill switches” in key infrastructure —
shutting down a wind turbine would be the equivalent of a windless day — but
concerns are real.
A second U.K. official said Britain had effectively categorized areas of the
economy into three buckets — “slam dunks” to engage with China, “slam dunks” to
block China, and everything in between. “We’ve been really clear [with China]
about which sectors are accessible,” they said, which had helped smooth the
path.
Then there are the litany of non-trade areas where China will be reluctant to
engage: being challenged on Xi’s relationship with Russian President Vladimir
Putin, the treatment of the Uyghur people and democracy campaigner Jimmy Lai.
Britain is still awaiting approval of a major revamp of its embassy in Beijing,
which will be expensive with U.K. contractors, materials and tech, all
security-cleared, being brought in.
3) STARMER AND HIS TEAM WERE GENUINELY LOVING IT
After such a build-up and so much controversy, Starmer has … been having a great
time. The prime minister has struggled to peel the smile off his face and told
business delegates they were “making history.”
Privately, several people around him enthused about the novelty of it all (many
have never visited China and Starmer has not done so since before he went into
politics). One said they were looking forward to seeing how Xi operates: “He’s
very enigmatic.”
Briefing journalists in a small ante-room in the Forbidden City, Starmer
enthused about Xi’s love of football and Shakespeare. And talking to business
leaders, he repeated the president’s line about blind men finding an elephant:
“One touches the leg and thinks it’s a pillow, another feels the belly and
thinks it’s a wall. Too often this reflects how China is seen.”
So into the spirit was Starmer that he even ticked off Kyle for not bowing
deeply enough. At the signing ceremony for a string of business deals, Kyle had
seen his counterpart bend halfway to the floor — and responded with a polite nod
of the head.
The vibes were energetic. Britain’s new ambassador to Beijing, Peter Wilson,
flitted around ceaselessly and sat along from Starmer in seat 1E. The PM’s No.
10 business adviser, Varun Chandra, jumped from CEO to CEO at the British
embassy.
The whole delegation was on burner phones and laptops (even leaving Apple
Watches at home) but the security fears soon faded to the background for U.K.
officials. CEOs on the trip queued up to tell journalists that Starmer was
making the right choice. “We risk a technological gulf if we don’t engage,” said
one.
There is one problem. Carry on like this, and Starmer will struggle to maintain
his line that he is not re-entering a “golden era” — like the one
controversially pushed by the Tories under David Cameron in the early 2010s —
after all.
4) BUSINESS WAS EVERYTHING
The trip was a tale of two groups of CEOs. The creatives and arts bosses gave
the stardust and human connection that such a controversial visit needed — but
business investment was the meat.
In his opening speech Starmer name-checked three people: Business Secretary
Peter Kyle, City Minister Lucy Rigby and No. 10 business adviser Varun Chandra.
It even came through in the seating plan on the chartered British Airways plane,
with financial services CEOs in the pricey seats while creatives were in economy
— although this was because they were all paying their own way.
Everyone knew the bargain. One arts CEO confessed that, while their industry
made money too, they knew they were not the uppermost priority.
Starmer’s aides insist they are delighted with what they managed to bag from Xi
on Thursday, and believe it is at the top end of the expectations they had on
the way out.
But that will mean the focus back home on the final “big number” of investment
that No. 10 produces — and the questions about whether it is worth all the
political energy — are even more acute.
5) STARMER’S STILL WALKING A TIGHTROPE
British CEOs were taken to see a collection of priceless Ming vases. It was a
good metaphor.
Starmer and the No. 10 operation were more reticent even than usual on Thursday,
refusing to give on-the-record comment about several basic details of what he
raised in his meeting with Xi. Journalists were told that he raised the case of
democracy campaigner Jimmy Lai, but not whether he called directly for his
release. The readout of the meeting from Communist China was more extensive (and
poetic) than that from No. 10.
Likewise, journalists were given no advance heads-up of deals on tariffs and
visas, even in the few hours between the bilateral and the announcements, while
the details and protocol were nailed down.
There was good reason for the reticence. Not only was Starmer cautious not to
offend his hosts; he also did not want to enrage U.S. President Donald Trump,
who threatened Canada with new tariffs after PM Mark Carney’s visit to Beijing
this month.
Even with No. 10 briefing the U.S. on the trip’s objectives beforehand, and
Starmer giving a pre-flight interview saying he wouldn’t choose between Xi and
Trump, the president called Britain’s engagement “very dangerous” on Friday.
And then there’s the EU. The longer Trump’s provocations go on, the more some of
Starmer’s more Europhile allies will want him to side not with the U.S. or
China, but Brussels.
“There’s this huge blind spot in the middle of Europe,” complained one European
diplomat. “The U.K. had the advantage of being the Trump whisperer, but that’s
gone now.”
Starmer leaves China hoping he can whisper to Trump, Xi and Ursula von der Leyen
all at the same time.
LONDON — It’s a far cry from the ice age of U.K.-China relations that
characterized Rishi Sunak’s leadership — and it’s not exactly David Cameron’s
“golden era,” either.
As U.K. Prime Minister Keir Starmer embarks on his Chinese charm offensive
against a turbulent economic backdrop, he has opted for a softly-softly approach
in a bid to warm up one of Britain’s most important trading partners — a marked
departure from his Tory predecessors.
With the specter of U.S. President Donald Trump looming over the visit — not to
mention national security concerns back home — Starmer’s cautious optimism is
hardly surprising.
Despite reservations from China skeptics, Starmer’s trip — the first such visit
by a British prime minister since 2018 — was peppered with warm words and a
smattering of deals, some more consequential than others.
Britain’s haul from the trip may be modest, but it’s just the beginning,
Business and Trade Secretary Peter Kyle — who joined Starmer on the trip — told
a traveling pack of reporters in Beijing.
“This visit is a springboard,” the minister said. “This is not the last moment,
it is a springboard into a future with far more action to come.”
STEP-BY-STEP
On the ground in Beijing, British officials gave the impression that the prime
minister was focused on getting as many uncontroversial wins over the line as
possible, in a bid to thaw relations with China.
That’s not to say Starmer and his team don’t have a few tangible wins to write
home about. Headline announcements include a commitment from China to allow
visa-free travel for British tourists and business travelers, enabling visits of
up to 30 days without the need for documents.
The provisions are similar to those extended to 50 other countries including
France, Germany, Italy, Australia and Japan. The timings of the visa change have
not yet been set out publicly, but one official — who, like others cited in this
piece, was granted anonymity to speak freely — said they were aiming to get it
nailed down in coming months.
“From a business standpoint, it will reduce a lot of friction,” said a British
business representative, adding it will make it easier for U.K. firms to explore
opportunities and form partnerships. “China is very complicated. You have to be
on the ground to really assess opportunities,” they said, adding visa-free
travel “will make things a lot easier.”
The commitment to visa-free travel forms part of a wider services package aimed
at driving collaboration for businesses in healthcare, financial and
professional services, legal services, education and skills — areas where
British firms often face regulatory or administrative hurdles.
The countries have also agreed to conduct a “feasibility study” to explore
whether to enter negotiations towards a bilateral services agreement. If it goes
ahead, this would establish clear and legally binding rules for U.K. firms doing
business in China. Once again, the timeframe is vague.
David Taylor, head of policy at the Asia House think tank in London, said “Xi’s
language has been warmer and more expansive, signaling interest in stabilizing
the relationship, but the substance on offer so far remains tightly defined.”
“Beyond the immediate announcements, progress — particularly on services and
professional access — will be harder and slower if it happens at all,” he added.
WHISKY TARIFF RELIEF
Another victory talked up by the British government is a plan for China to slash
Scotch whisky tariffs by half, from 10 percent to 5 percent.
However, some may question the scale of the commitment, which effectively
restores the rate that was in place one year ago, ahead of a doubling of the
rate for whisky and brandy in February 2025.
The two sides have not yet set out a timeframe for the reduction of tariffs.
Speaking to POLITICO ahead of Starmer’s trip, a senior business representative
said the whisky and brandy issue had become “China leverage” in talks leading up
to the visit. However, they argued that even a removal of the tariff was “not
going to solve the main issue for British whisky companies in China and
everywhere, which is that people aren’t buying and drinking whisky.”
CHINA INVESTMENT WIN
Meanwhile, China can boast a significant win in the form of a $15 billion
investment in medicines manufacturing and research and development from British
pharmaceutical giant AstraZeneca.
ING Bank’s global healthcare lead Stephen Farelly said that increasing
investment into China “makes good business sense,” given the country is “now
becoming a force in biopharma.” However, it “does shine a light on the isolation
of Europe and the U.K. more generally, where there is a structural decline in
investment and R&D.”
AstraZeneca recently paused a £200 million investment at a Cambridge research
site in September last year, which was due to create 1,000 jobs.
Britain recently increased the amount the NHS pays for branded, pharmaceutical
drugs, following heavy industry lobbying and following trade negotiations with
the Trump administration — all in the hopes of attracting new investment into
the struggling sector.
Shadow Trade Secretary Andrew Griffith was blunt in his assessment.
“AstraZeneca’s a great British company but under this government it’s investing
everywhere in the world other than its U.K. home. When we are losing investment
to communist China, alarm bells should be ringing in No 10 Downing Street.”
Conspicuously absent from Starmer’s haul was any mention of net zero
infrastructure imports, like solar panels, a reflection of rising concerns about
China’s grip on Britain’s critical infrastructure.
XI RETURNS
So what next? As Starmer prepares to fly back home, attention has already turned
to his next encounter with the Chinese leader.
On Thursday, Britain opened the door to an inward visit by Xi Jinping, with
Downing Street repeatedly declining to rule out the prospect of welcoming him in
future.
Asked about the prospect of an inward visit — which would be the first for 11
years — Starmer’s official spokesperson told reporters: “I think the prime
minister has been clear that a reset relationship with China, that it’s no
longer in an ice age, is beneficial to British people and British business.”
As Starmer’s trip draws to a close, one thing is certain: there is more to come.
“This isn’t a question of a one-and-done summit with China,” Starmer’s
spokesperson added. “It is a resetting of a relationship that has been on ice
for eight years.”
BEIJING — Britain on Thursday opened the door to an inward visit by Xi Jinping
after the Chinese president hailed a thawing of relations between the two
nations.
Downing Street repeatedly declined to rule out the prospect of welcoming Xi in
future after saying that Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s current visit to China
would not be a “one-and-done summit.”
Asked about the prospect of an inward visit — which would be the first for 11
years — Starmer’s official spokesperson told reporters: “I think the prime
minister has been clear that a reset relationship with China, that it’s no
longer in an ice age, is beneficial to British people and British business.
“I’m not going to get ahead of future engagements. We’ll set those out in the
normal way.”
Xi paid a full state visit to the U.K. in 2015 and visited a traditional pub
with then-Prime Minister David Cameron, during what is now seen as a “golden
era” of British-Chinese relations. Critics of China’s stance on human rights and
espionage see the trip as one of the worst foreign policy misjudgments of the
Cameron era.
Kemi Badenoch, leader of the opposition Conservative Party, said: “We should not
roll out the red carpet for a state that conducts daily espionage in our
country, flouts international trading rules and aids Putin in his senseless war
on Ukraine. We need a dialogue with China, we do not need to kowtow to them.”
Any state visit invitation would be in the name of King Charles III and be
issued by Buckingham Palace. There is no suggestion that a full state visit is
being considered at present.
Xi did not leave mainland China for more than two years during the Covid-19
pandemic.
Starmer and Xi met Thursday in Beijing’s Great Hall of the People and the two
nations agreed to look at the “feasibility” of a partnership in the services
sector.
Britain said it had signed an agreement for China to waive visa rules for
British citizens visiting for less than 30 days for business or tourism,
bringing the U.K. into line with nations including France, Germany, Italy,
Australia and Japan.
The two nations also promised to co-operate on conformity assessments, exports,
sports, tackling organized crime, vocational training and food safety, though
further details were not immediately available. Starmer also hailed “really good
progress” on lowering Chinese whisky tariffs.
One official familiar with the talks stressed that Starmer had also raised more
difficult issues including the ongoing detention of British-Hong Kong democracy
campaigner Jimmy Lai, and China’s position on the war in Ukraine — but declined
to be drawn on the specifics of the pair’s conversation.
The talks steered clear of more difficult topics such as wind farm technology,
where critics fear co-operation would leave Britain vulnerable to Chinese
influence.
Asked if Starmer had come back empty handed, his spokesperson said: “I don’t
accept that at all. I think this is a historic trip where you’ve seen for the
first time in eight years a PM set foot on Chinese soil, have a meeting at the
highest level with the president of the second largest economy in the world.
“You should also note that this isn’t a question of a one-and-done summit with
China. It is a resetting of a relationship that has been on ice for eight
years.”
The U.K. and China have announced a new services partnership to support British
businesses operating in China, including through visa-free travel for short
stays.
The partnership will see Beijing relax its visa rules for British citizens,
adding the U.K. to its visa-free list of countries. This will enable visits of
up to 30 days for business and tourism without the need for a visa. The timings
of the visa change have not yet been set out.
The partnership focuses on better collaboration for businesses in healthcare,
financial and professional services, legal services, education and skills —
areas where British firms often face regulatory or administrative hurdles.
Britain and China have also agreed to conduct a “feasibility study” to explore
whether to enter negotiations towards a bilateral services agreement. If it
proceeds, this would establish clear and legally binding rules for U.K. firms
doing business in China.
Prime Minister Keir Starmer said: “As one of the world’s economic powerhouses,
businesses have been crying out for ways to grow their footprints in China.
“We’ll make it easier for them to do so – including via relaxed visa rules for
short-term travel — supporting them to expand abroad, all while boosting growth
and jobs at home.”
The U.K. and China have also signed pacts covering co-operation on conformity
assessments for exports from the U.K. to China, food safety, animal, and plant
quarantine health and the work the UK-China Joint Economic and Trade Commission.
The two sides aren’t planning to publish the full texts of the pacts.
BEIJING — U.K. Prime Minister Keir Starmer has hailed “really good progress” on
Chinese whisky tariffs and visa-free travel after a lengthy meeting with Chinese
President Xi Jinping.
Starmer dubbed the one hour and 20 minute sit-down with Xi as “a very good
productive session with real, concrete outcomes, [which was] a real
strengthening of the relationship.”
Speaking to reporters after the meeting, he said: “We made some really good
progress on tariffs for whisky, on visa free travel to China and on information
exchange.”
The news will be welcomed by Scotch whisky exporters, who have been squeezed by
U.S. President Donald Trump’s 10 percent baseline tariffs on imported U.K.
goods.
Currently, Scotch whisky exports face 10 percent duties in China, after the
country doubled its import tariffs on brandy and whisky in February 2025,
removing its provisional 5 percent rate.
Exports to China fell by 31 percent last year, sliding from China’s
fifth-largest export market to its tenth.
“We’ve agreed that on tariffs for whisky, we’re looking at how they’re to be
reduced, what the timeframe is,” said Starmer.
The two sides also made progress on visa-free travel to China for short stays —
which would allow British citizens to visit for tourism, business conferences,
family visits, and short exchange activities without requiring a visa.
Britain is currently not among the European countries granted visa-free access
to China, a list that includes France, Germany, Italy, Spain, and Switzerland.
Starmer said the two sides are now looking at “how far, how much, and when that
can start.”
China issued its own readout via state news agency Xinhua, where it discussed
expanded cooperation in “education, healthcare, finance, and services, and
conduct joint research and industrial transformation in fields such as
artificial intelligence, bioscience, new energy, and low-carbon technologies to
achieve common development and prosperity.”
The Chinese statement said both sides should “strengthen people-to-people
exchanges and further facilitate personnel exchanges,” adding that China “is
willing to actively consider implementing unilateral visa-free entry for the
U.K.”
Starmer and Chinese Premier Li Qiang are due to sign memorandums of
understanding covering cooperation in a number of areas at a signing ceremony on
Thursday morning U.K. time.
Starmer and Li will also sign a border security pact to enlist Beijing’s help in
choking off the supply of small boat engines and equipment used by criminal
gangs to facilitate Channel crossings
POLITICO first reported earlier this month that the U.K. was pushing to secure
visa-free travel and lower whisky tariffs.
This developing story is being updated.
LONDON — U.K. Prime Minister Keir Starmer is braced for a meeting with Chinese
leader Xi Jinping — and there’ll be more than a few elephants in the room.
Though Britain has improved its relationship with China following the more
combative approach of previous Conservative administrations, a litany of
concerns over national security and human rights continues to dog Labour’s
attempted refresh.
Starmer, who will meet the Chinese president in Beijing Thursday morning, told
reporters engaging with China means he can discuss “issues where we disagree.”
“You know that in the past, on all the trips I’ve done, I’ve always raised
issues that need to be raised,” he said during a huddle with journalists on the
British Airways flight to China on Tuesday evening.
In a sign of how hard it can be to engage on more tricky subjects, Chinese
officials bundled the British press out of the room when Starmer tried to bring
up undesirable topics the last time the pair met.
From hacking and spying to China’s foreign policy aims, POLITICO has a handy
guide to all the ways Starmer could rile up the Chinese president.
1) STATE-SPONSORED HACKING
China is one of the biggest offenders in cyberspace and is regarded by the
U.K.’s National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) — part of Britain’s GCHQ
intelligence agency — as a “highly sophisticated threat actor.” The Electoral
Commission said it has taken three years to recover from a Chinese hack of its
systems.
The Chinese state, and private companies linked directly or obliquely to its
cyber and espionage agencies, have been directly accused by the British
government, its intelligence agencies and allies. As recently as last month, the
U.K. government sanctioned two Chinese companies — both named by the U.S. as
linked to Chinese intelligence — for hacking Britain and its allies.
2) ACTIONS AGAINST BRITISH PARLIAMENTARIANS
Politicians in Britain who have spoken out against Chinese human rights abuses
and hostile activity have been censured by Beijing in recent years. This
includes the sanctioning of 5 British MPs in 2021, including the former security
minister Tom Tugendhat, who has been banned from entering the country.
Last year, Liberal Democrat MP Wera Hobhouse was refused entry to Hong Kong
while attempting to visit her grandson, and was turned back by officials. The
government said that the case was raised with Chinese authorities during a visit
to China by Douglas Alexander, who was trade minister at the time.
3) JIMMY LAI
In 2020, the British-Hong Kong businessman and democracy campaigner Jimmy Lai
was arrested under national security laws imposed by Beijing and accused of
colluding with a foreign state. Lai — who is in his late 70s — has remained in
prison ever since.
Last month, a Hong Kong court convicted Lai of three offenses following what his
supporters decried as a 156-day show trial. He is currently awaiting the final
decisions relating to sentencing — with bodies including the EU parliament
warning that a life imprisonment could have severe consequences for Europe’s
relationship with China if he is not released. Lai’s son last year called for
the U.K. government to make his father’s release a precondition of closer
relations with Beijing.
4) REPRESSION OF DISSIDENTS
China, like Iran, is involved in the active monitoring and intimidation of those
it considers dissidents on foreign soil — known as trans-national repression.
China and Hong Kong law enforcement agencies have repeatedly issued arrest
warrants for nationals living in Britain and other Western countries.
British police in 2022 were forced to investigate an assault on a protester
outside the Chinese consulate in Manchester. The man was beaten by several men
after being dragged inside the grounds of the diplomatic building during a
demonstration against Xi Jinping. China removed six officials from Britain
before they could be questioned.
5) CHINESE SPY SCANDALS
Westminster was last year rocked by a major Chinese spying scandal involving two
British men accused of monitoring British parliamentarians and passing
information back to Beijing. Though the case against the two men collapsed, the
MI5 intelligence agency still issued an alert to MPs, peers and their staff,
warning Chinese intelligence officers were “attempting to recruit people with
access to sensitive information about the British state.”
It is not the only China spy allegation to embroil the upper echelons of British
society. Yang Tengbo, who in 2024 outed himself as an alleged spy banned from
entering the U.K., was a business associate of Andrew Windsor , the` disgraced
brother of King Charles. Christine Lee, a lawyer who donated hundreds of
thousands of pounds to a Labour MP, was the subject of a security alert from
British intelligence.
In October, Ken McCallum, the head of MI5, said that his officers had
“intervened operationally” against China that month.
6) EMBASSY DING DONG
This month — after a protracted political and planning battle — the government
approved the construction of a Chinese “super-embassy” in London. This came
after a litany of security concerns were raised by MPs and in the media,
including the building’s proximity to sensitive cables, which it is alleged
could be used to aid Chinese spying.
Britain has its own embassy headache in China. Attempts to upgrade the U.K.
mission in Beijing were reportedly blocked while China’s own London embassy plan
was in limbo.
7) SANCTIONS EVASION
China has long been accused of helping facilitate sanctions evasion for
countries such as Russia and Iran. Opaque customs and trade arrangements have
allegedly allowed prohibited shipments of oil and dual-use technology to flow
into countries that are sanctioned by Britain and its allies.
Britain has already sanctioned some Chinese companies accused of aiding Russia’s
war in Ukraine. China has called for Britain to stop making “groundless
accusations” about its involvement in Russia’s war efforts.
8) HUMAN RIGHTS ABUSES AND GREEN ENERGY
U.K. ministers are under pressure from MPs and human rights organizations to get
tougher on China over reported human rights abuses in the country’s Xinjiang
region — where many of the world’s solar components are sourced.
In a meeting with China’s Vice Premier Ding Xuexiang last March, Energy
Secretary Ed Miliband raised the issue of forced labor in supply chains,
according to a government readout of the meeting. But he also stressed the need
for deeper collaboration with China as the U.K.’s lofty clean power goal looms.
British academic Laura Murphy — who was researching the risk of forced labor in
supply chains — had her work halted by Sheffield Hallam University amid claims
of pressure from China. “I know that there are other researchers who don’t feel
safe speaking out in public, who are experiencing similar things, although often
more subtly,” Murphy said last year.
9) THE FUTURE OF TAIWAN
China continues to assert that “Taiwan is a province of China” amid reports it
is stepping up preparations for military intervention in the region.
In October, the Telegraph newspaper published an op-ed from the Chinese
ambassador to Britain, which said: “Taiwan has never been a country. There is
but one China, and both sides of the Taiwan Strait belong to one and the same
China.”
In a sign of just how sensitive the matter is, Beijing officials reportedly
threatened to cancel high-level trade talks between China and the U.K. after
Alexander, then a trade minister, travelled to Taipei last June.
10) CHINA POOTLING AROUND THE ARCTIC
Britain is pushing for greater European and NATO involvement in the Arctic amid
concern that both China and Russia are becoming more active in the strategically
important area. There is even more pressure to act, with U.S. President Donald
Trump making clear his Greenland aspirations.
In October, a Chinese container ship completed a pioneering journey through the
Arctic to a U.K. port — halving the usual time it takes to transport electric
cars and solar panels destined for Europe.
ABOARD THE PRIME MINISTER’S PLANE TO BEIJING — Keir Starmer rejected his
Canadian counterpart’s call for mid-sized countries to band together in the face
of unpredictable global powers — and insisted his “common sense” British
approach will do just fine.
The British prime minister arrives in China Wednesday for a trip aimed at
rebooting the U.K.’s relationship with the Asian superpower. He’s the latest
Western leader to make the visit — which will include a meeting with Chinese
President Xi Jinping — after trips by Carney and France’s Emmanuel Macron.
Carney used a searing speech at the World Economic Forum last week to warn of
the “rupture” caused by “great powers” acting in their own self-interest. While
he did not namecheck Donald Trump’s administration, the speech riled the U.S.
president, who insisted: “Canada lives because of the United States.”
The Canadian PM had called for middle powers to work together to “build
something bigger, better, stronger, more just.”
Starmer was pressed on those remarks on board his flight to China Tuesday. Asked
whether he agreed that the old global order is dead — and whether smaller powers
need to team up to push back at the U.S. and China, Starmer defended his own
policy of trying to build bridges with Trump, Xi and the European Union all at
once.
“I’m a pragmatist, a British pragmatist applying common sense, and therefore I’m
pleased that we have a good relationship with the U.S. on defense, security,
intelligence and on trade and prosperity,” he says. “It’s very important that we
maintain that good relationship.”
He added: “Equally, we are moving forward with a better relationship with the
EU. We had a very good summit last year with 10 strands of agreement.
“We’ll have another summit this year with the EU, which I hope will be
iterative, as well as following through on what we’ve already agreed.
“And I’ve consistently said I’m not choosing between the U.S. and Europe. I’m
really glad that the UK has got good relations with both.”
Starmer’s government — which faces pressure from opposition parties back home as
it re-engages with China — has stressed that it wants to cooperate, compete with
and challenge Beijing when necessary, as it bids to build economic ties to aid
the sputtering U.K. economy.
“Obviously, China is the second biggest economy in the world, one of our biggest
trading partners,” the British PM — who is flying with an entourage of British
CEOs and business reps — said Tuesday. “And under the last government, we veered
from the golden age to the ice age. And what I want to do is follow through on
the approach I’ve set out a number of times now … which is a comprehensive and
consistent approach to China.
“I do think there are opportunities, but obviously we will never compromise
national security in taking those opportunities.”
LONDON — Keir Starmer is off to China to try to lock in some economic wins he
can shout about back home. But some of the trickiest trade issues are already
being placed firmly in the “too difficult” box.
The U.K.’s trade ministry quietly dispatched several delegations to Beijing over
the fall to hash out deals with the Chinese commerce ministry and lay the
groundwork for the British prime minister’s visit, which gets going in earnest
Wednesday.
But the visit comes as Britain faces growing pressure from its Western allies to
combat Chinese industrial overproduction — and just weeks after Starmer handed
his trade chief new powers to move faster in imposing tariffs on cheap,
subsidized imports from countries like China.
For now, then, the aim is to secure progress in areas that are seen as less
sensitive.
Starmer’s delegation of CEOs and chairs will split their time between Beijing
and Shanghai, with executives representing City giants and high-profile British
brands including HSBC, Standard Chartered, Schroders, and the London Stock
Exchange Group, alongside AstraZeneca, Jaguar Land Rover, Octopus Energy, and
Brompton filling out the cast list. Starmer will be flanked on his visit by
Trade Secretary Peter Kyle and City Minister Lucy Rigby.
Despite the weighty delegation, ministers insist the approach is deliberately
narrow.
“We have a very clear-eyed approach when it comes to China,” Security Minister
Dan Jarvis said Monday. “Where it is in our national interest to cooperate and
work closely with [China], then we will do so. But when it’s our national
security interest to safeguard against the threats that [they] pose, we will
absolutely do that.”
Starmer’s wishlist will be carefully calibrated not to rock the boat. Drumming
up Chinese cash for heavy energy infrastructure, including sensitive wind
turbine technology, is off the table.
Instead, the U.K. has been pushing for lower whisky tariffs, improved market
access for services firms, recognition of professional qualifications, banking
and insurance licences for British companies operating in China, easier
cross-border investment, and visa-free travel for short stays.
With China fiercely protective of its domestic market, some of those asks will
be easier said than done. Here’s POLITICO’s pro guide to where it could get
bumpy.
CHAMPIONING THE CITY OF LONDON
Britain’s share of China’s services market was a modest 2.7 percent in 2024 —
and U.K. firms are itching for more work in the country.
British officials have been pushing for recognition of professional
qualifications for accountants, designers and architects — which would allow
professionals to practice in China without re-licensing locally — and visa-free
travel for short stays.
Vocational accreditation is a “long-standing issue” in the bilateral
relationship, with “little movement” so far on persuading Beijing to recognize
U.K. professional credentials as equivalent to its own, according to a senior
industry representative familiar with the talks, who, like others in this
report, was granted anonymity to speak freely.
But while the U.K.’s allies in the European Union and the U.S. have imposed
tariffs on Chinese EVs, the U.K. has resisted pressure to do so. | Jessica
Lee/EPA
Britain is one of the few developed countries still missing from China’s
visa-free list, which now includes France, Germany, Italy, Spain, the
Netherlands, Switzerland, Australia, New Zealand, Japan, Saudi Arabia, Russia
and Sweden.
Starmer is hoping to mirror a deal struck by Canadian PM Mark Carney, whose own
China visit unlocked visa-free travel for Canadians.
The hope is that easier business travel will reduce friction and make it easier
for people to travel and explore opportunities on the ground — it would allow
visa-free travel for British citizens, giving them the ability to travel for
tourism, attend business conferences, visit friends and family, and participate
in short exchange activities.
SMOOTHING FINANCIAL FLOWS
The Financial Conduct Authority’s Chair Ashley Alder is also flying out to
Beijing, hoping to secure closer alignment between the two countries’ capital
markets. He’ll represent Britain’s financial watchdog at the inaugural U.K-China
Financial Working Group in Beijing — and bang the drum for better market
connectivity between the U.K. and China.
Expect emphasis on the cross-border investments mechanism known as the
Shanghai-London and Shenzhen-London Stock Connect, plus data sovereignty issues
associated with Chinese companies jointly listing on the London Stock Exchange,
two figures familiar with the planning said.
The Stock Connect opened up both markets to investors in 2019 which, according
to FCA Chair Ashley Alder, led to listings worth almost $6 billion.
“Technical obstacles have so far prevented us from realizing Stock Connect’s
full potential,” Alder said in a speech last year. Alder pointed to a memorandum
of understanding being drawn up between the FCA and China’s National Financial
Regulatory Administration, which he said is “critical” to allow information to
be shared quickly and for firms to be supervised across borders. But that raises
its own concerns about Chinese use of data.
“The goods wins are easier,” said a senior British business representative
briefed on the talks. “Some of the service ones are more difficult.”
TAPPING INTO CHINA’S BIOTECH BOOM
Pharma executives, including AstraZeneca’s CEO Pascal Soriot, are among those
heading to China, as Britain tries to burnish its credentials as a global life
sciences hub — and attract foreign direct investment.
China, once known mainly for generics — cheaper versions of branded medicine
that deliver the same treatment — has rapidly emerged as a pharma powerhouse.
According to ING Bank’s global healthcare lead, Stephen Farrelly, the country
has “effectively replaced Europe” as a center of innovation.
ING data shows China’s share of global innovative drug approvals jumped from
just 4 percent in 2014 to 27 percent in 2024.
Pharma executives, including AstraZeneca’s CEO Pascal Soriot, are among those
heading to China, as Britain tries to burnish its credentials as a global life
sciences hub — and attract foreign direct investment. | John G. Mabanglo/EPA
Several blockbuster drug patents are set to expire in the coming years, opening
the door for cheaper generic competitors. To refill thinning pipelines,
drugmakers are increasingly turning to biotech companies. British pharma giant
GSK signed a licensing deal with Chinese biotech firm Hengrui Pharma last July.
“Because of the increasing relevance of China, the big pharma industry and the
U.K. by definition is now looking to China as a source of those new innovative
therapies,” Farrelly said.
There are already signs of progress. Science Minister Patrick Vallance said late
last year that the U.K. and China are ready to work together in
“uncontroversial” areas, including health, after talks with his Chinese
counterpart. AstraZeneca, the University of Cambridge and Beijing municipal
parties have already signed a partnership to share expertise.
And earlier this year, the U.K. announced plans to become a “global first choice
for clinical trials.”
“The U.K. can really help China with the trust gap” when it comes to getting
drugs onto the market, said Quin Wills, CEO of Ochre, a biotech company
operating in New York, Oxford and Taiwan. “The U.K. could become a global gold
stamp for China. We could be like a regulatory bridgehead where [healthcare
regulator] MHRA, now separate from the EU since Brexit, can do its own thing and
can maybe offer a 150-day streamlined clinical approval process for China as
part of a broader agreement.”
SLASHING WHISKY TARIFFS
The U.K. has also been pushing for lowered tariffs on whisky alongside wider
agri-food market access, according to two of the industry figures familiar with
the planning cited earlier.
Talks at the end of 2024 between then-Trade Secretary Jonathan Reynolds and his
Chinese counterpart ended Covid-era restrictions on exports, reopening pork
market access.
But in February 2025 China doubled its import tariffs on brandy and whisky,
removing its provisional 5 percent tariff and applying the 10 percent
most-favored-nation rate.
“The whisky and brandy issue became China leverage,” said the senior British
business representative briefed on the talks. “I think that they’re probably
going to get rid of the tariff.”
It’s not yet clear how China would lower whisky tariffs without breaching World
Trade Organization rules, which say it would have to lower its tariffs to all
other countries too.
INDUSTRIAL TENSIONS
The trip comes as the U.K. faces growing international pressure to take a
tougher line on Chinese industrial overproduction, particularly of steel and
electric cars.
But in February 2025 China doubled its import tariffs on brandy and whisky,
removing its provisional 5 percent tariff and applying the 10 percent
most-favored-nation rate. | Yonhap/EPA
But while the U.K.’s allies in the European Union and the U.S. have imposed
tariffs on Chinese EVs, the U.K. has resisted pressure to do so.
There’s a deal “in the works” between Chinese EV maker and Jaguar Land Rover,
said the senior British business representative briefed on the talks quoted
higher, where the two are “looking for a big investment announcement. But
nothing has been agreed.” The deal would see the Chinese EV maker use JLR’s
factory in the U.K. to build cars in Britain, the FT reported last week.
“Chinese companies are increasingly focused on localising their operations,”
said another business representative familiar with the talks, noting Chinese EV
makers are “realising that just flaunting their products overseas won’t be a
sustainable long term model.”
It’s unlikely Starmer will land a deal on heavy energy infrastructure, including
wind turbine technology, that could leave Britain vulnerable to China. The U.K.
has still not decided whether to let Ming Yang, a Chinese firm, invest £1.5
billion in a wind farm off the coast of Scotland.