Denmark’s top military commander in the Arctic pushed back against claims that
Greenland is facing an imminent security threat from Russia or China,
undercutting a narrative repeatedly advanced by U.S. President Donald Trump.
“No. We don’t see a threat from China or Russia today,” Major General Søren
Andersen, commander of Denmark’s Joint Arctic Command in Greenland, said in an
interview with the Axel Springer Global Reporters Network, of which POLITICO is
a part. “But we look into a potential threat, and that is what we are training
for.”
Andersen, who has headed the Joint Arctic Command since 2023, stressed that the
stepped-up Danish and allied military activity around Greenland is not a
response to an immediate danger, but preparation for future contingencies.
Once the war in Ukraine ends, he said, Moscow could redirect military resources
to other regions. “I actually expect that we will see Russian resources that are
being taken from the theater around Ukraine into other theaters,” Andersen said,
pointing to the Baltic Sea and the Arctic region.
That assessment has driven Denmark’s decision to expand exercises and invite
European allies to operate in and around Greenland under harsh winter
conditions, part of what Copenhagen has framed as strengthening NATO’s northern
flank. Troops from several European countries have already deployed under
Denmark’s Operation Arctic Endurance exercise, which includes air, maritime and
land components.
The remarks stand in contrast to Trump’s repeated claims that Greenland is under
active pressure from Russia and China and his insistence that the island is
vital to U.S. national security.
“In the meantime, you have Russian destroyers and submarines, and China
destroyers and submarines all over the place,” Trump told reporters on Sunday
about his pursuit to make Greenland part of the United States. “We’re not going
to let that happen.”
Trump has argued Washington cannot rule out the use of force to secure its
interests, comments that have alarmed Danish and Greenlandic leaders.
Andersen declined to engage directly with those statements, instead emphasizing
NATO unity and longstanding cooperation with U.S. forces already stationed at
Pituffik Space Base. He also rejected hypothetical scenarios involving conflict
between allies, saying he could not envision one NATO country attacking another.
Despite rising political tensions with Washington, Andersen said the United
States was formally invited to participate in the exercise. “I hope that also
that we will have U.S. troops together with German, France or Canadian, or
whatever force that will train, because I think we have to do this together.”
Tag - Baltic Sea
A cargo ship that sailed from Russia was detained in the Gulf of Finland on
Wednesday following damage to an underwater data cable linking Finland and
Estonia.
“A ship that was in the area at the time of the cable damage between Helsinki
and Tallinn has been diverted to Finnish waters,” Prime Minister Petteri Orpo
posted on X. “The government is closely monitoring the situation.”
The Fitburg, which was under the flag of Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, had
departed St. Petersburg, Russia on Dec. 30 and was en route to Israel with crew
from Russia, Azerbaijan, Georgia and Kazakhstan. Telecoms provider Elisa
notified authorities at 5 a.m. of a cable break in Estonia’s exclusive economic
zone, which extends 200 nautical miles from its coast.
Hours later a Finnish patrol vessel caught the Fitburg with its anchor in the
water in Finland’s exclusive economic zone, the country’s coast guard reported.
“At the moment we suspect aggravated disruption of telecommunications and also
aggravated sabotage and attempted aggravated sabotage,” Helsinki police chief
Jari Liukku told media.
“Finland is prepared for security challenges of various kinds, and we respond to
them as necessary,” President Alexander Stubb said on X.
Earlier this year the NATO military alliance launched its “Baltic Sentry”
program to stop attacks against subsea energy and data cables in the Baltic Sea
that have multiplied following Russia’s 2022 invasion of Ukraine. The sabotage
has included the severing of an internet cable between Finland and Germany in
November 2024 and another between Finland and Sweden the following month.
A July study by the University of Washington found that 10 subsea cables in the
Baltic Sea had been cut since 2022. “A majority of these incidents have raised
suspicions of sabotage by state actors, specifically Russia and China, who have
been particularly active in the region,” the study noted.
Denmark’s military intelligence service has for the first time classified the
U.S. as a security risk, a striking shift in how one of Washington’s closest
European allies assesses the transatlantic relationship.
In its 2025 intelligence outlook published Wednesday, the Danish Defense
Intelligence Service warned that the U.S. is increasingly prioritizing its own
interests and “using its economic and technological strength as a tool of
power,” including toward allies and partners.
“The United States uses economic power, including in the form of threats of high
tariffs, to enforce its will and no longer excludes the use of military force,
even against allies,” it said, in a pointed reference to Washington trying to
wrest control of Greenland from Denmark.
The assessment is one of the strongest warnings about the U.S. to come from a
European intelligence service. In October, the Dutch spies said they had stopped
sharing some intelligence with their U.S. counterparts, citing political
interference and human rights concerns.
The Danish warning underscores European unease as Washington leverages
industrial policy more aggressively on the global stage, and highlights the
widening divide between the allies, with the U.S. National Security Strategy
stating that Europe will face the “prospect of civilizational erasure” within
the next 20 years.
The Danish report also said that “there is uncertainty about how China-U.S.
relations will develop in the coming years” as Beijing’s rapid rise has eroded
the U.S.’s long-held position as the undisputed global power.
Washington and Beijing are now locked in a contest for influence, alliances and
critical resources, which has meant the U.S. has “significantly prioritized” the
geographical area around it — including the Arctic — to reduce China’s
influence.
“The USA’s increasingly strong focus on the Pacific Ocean is also creating
uncertainty about the country’s role as the primary guarantor of security in
Europe,” the report said. “The USA’s changed policy places great demands on
armaments and cooperation between European countries to strengthen deterrence
against Russia.”
In the worst-case scenario, the Danish intelligence services predict that
Western countries could find themselves in a situation in a few years where both
Russia and China are ready to fight their own regional wars in the Baltic Sea
region and the Taiwan Strait, respectively.
Elisabeth Braw is a senior fellow at the Atlantic Council, the author of the
award-winning “Goodbye Globalization” and a regular columnist for POLITICO.
Russia’s shadow fleet just won’t go away.
Countries in the Baltic Sea region have tried virtually every legal means of
stopping this gnawing headache for every country whose waters have been
traversed by these mostly dilapidated vessels — and yes, sinking them would be
illegal.
Now, these rust buckets are starting to cause an additional headache. Because
they’re usually past retirement age, these vessels don’t last long before they
need to be scrapped. This has opened a whole shadow trade that’s bound to cause
serious harm to both humans and the environment.
Earlier this month, the globally infamous Eagle S ship met its end in the
Turkish port of Aliağa. The bow of the 229-meter oil tanker was on shore, its
stern afloat, with cranes disassembling and moving its parts into a sealed area.
The negative environmental impact of this landing method “is no doubt higher
than recycling in a fully contained area,” noted the NGO Shipbreaking Platform
on its website.
But in the grand scheme of things, the Eagle S’s end was a relatively clean one.
The 19-year-old Cook Islands-flagged oil tanker is a shadow vessel that had been
transporting sanctioned Russian oil since early 2023. It then savaged an
astonishing five undersea cables in the Gulf of Finland on Christmas Day last
year, before being detained by the Finnish authorities.
People are willing to own shadow vessels because they can make a lot of money
transporting sanctioned cargo. However, as the tiny, elusive outfits that own
them would struggle to buy shiny new vessels even if they wanted to, these ships
are often on their last legs — different surveys estimate that shadow vessels
have an average age of 20 years or more.
Over the last few years, Russia’s embrace of the shadow fleet for its oil export
has caused the fleet to grow dramatically, as tanker owners concluded they can
make good money by selling their aging ships into the fleet. (They’d make less
selling the vessels to shipbreakers.) Today, the shadow fleet encompasses the
vast majority of retirement-age oil tankers. But after a few years, these
tankers and ships are simply too old to sail, especially since shadow vessels
undergo only the most cursory maintenance.
To get around safely rules, less-than-scrupulous owners often sell their nearly
dead ships to “final journey” firms, which have the sole purpose of disposing of
them. | Ole Berg-Rusten/EPA
For aged ships, the world of official shipping has what one might call a funeral
process: a scrapping market.
In 2024, 409 ships were scrapped through this official market, though calling it
“official” makes it sound clean and safe, which, for the most part, it isn’t. A
few of the ships scrapped last year were disassembled in countries like Denmark,
Norway and the Netherlands, which follow strict rules regarding human and
environmental safety. A handful of others were scrapped in Turkey, which has an
OK record. But two-thirds were scrapped in Southeast Asia, where the
shipbreaking industry is notoriously unsafe.
To get around safely rules, less-than-scrupulous owners often sell their nearly
dead ships to “final journey” firms, which have the sole purpose of disposing of
them. These companies and their middlemen then make money by selling the ships’
considerable amount of steel to metal companies. But in India, Pakistan and
Bangladesh — the latter is the world’s most popular shipbreaking country —
vessels are disassembled on beaches rather than sealed facilities, and by
workers using little more than their hands.
Of course, this makes the process cheap, but it also makes it dangerous.
According to the NGO Shipbreaking Platform, last year, 15 South Asian
shipbreaking workers lost their lives on the job and 45 were injured. Just one
accident involving an oil tanker claimed the lives of six workers and injured
another six.
This brings us to the shadow fleet and its old vessels, as they, too, need to be
scrapped. But many of them are under Western sanctions, which presents a
challenge to their owners since international financial transactions are
typically conducted in U.S. dollars.
Initially, I had suspected that coastal nations would start finding all manner
of shadow vessels abandoned in their waters and would be left having to arrange
the scrapping. But as owners want to make money from the ships’ metal, this
frightening scenario hasn’t come to pass. Instead, a shadow shipbreaking market
is emerging.
Open-source intelligence research shows that shadow vessel owners are now
selling their sanctioned vessels to final-journey firms or middlemen in a
process that mirror the official one. Given that these are mostly sanctioned
vessels, the buyers naturally get a discount, which the sellers are more than
willing to provide. After all, selling a larger shadow tanker for scrap value
and making something to the tune of $10 to $15 million is more profitable than
abandoning it.
And how are the payments made? We don’t know for sure, but they’re likely in
crypto or a non-U.S. dollar currency.
These shady processes make the situation even more perilous for the workers
doing the scrapping, not to mention for the environment. “Thanks to a string of
new rules and regulations over the past five decades, shipping has become much
safer, and that has reduced the number of accidents significantly in recent
decades,” explained Mats Saether, a lawyer at the Nordisk legal services
association in Oslo. “It’s regrettable that the shadow fleet is reversing this
trend.” It certainly is.
Indeed, the scrapping of shadow vessels is a practice that demands serious
scrutiny. Greenpeace, Human Rights Watch and other NGOs could do a good deed for
the environment and unfortunate shipbreaking workers by conducting
investigations. And surely the Bangladeshi government wouldn’t want to see
Bangladeshi lives lost because Russia needs oil for war?
Greenpeace, Human Rights Watch and other NGOs could do a good deed for the
environment and unfortunate shipbreaking workers by conducting investigations. |
Ole Berg-Rusten/EPA
There’s an opportunity here for Western governments to help too. They could
offer shadow vessel owners legal leniency and a way to sell their ships back
into the official fleet — if the owners provide the authorities with details
about the fleet’s inner workings and vow to leave the business.
Does that sound unlikely to succeed? Possibly. But that’s what people said about
Italy’s pentiti system, and they were proven wrong. Besides, the shadow fleet is
such a tumor on the shipping industry and the world’s waterways that almost any
measure is worth a try.
Listen on
* Spotify
* Apple Music
* Amazon Music
In dieser Spezialfolge des Berlin Playbook Updates berichtet Rixa Fürsen von der
Berliner Sicherheitskonferenz – wo Generäle, Verteidigungsminister und
sicherheitspolitische Entscheider Europas über Abschreckung, Aufrüstung und die
Zukunft der NATO sprechen. Partnerland in diesem Jahr: Schweden.
Rixa trifft Pål Jonson, den schwedischen Verteidigungsminister und spricht mit
ihm über die historische Kehrtwende seines Landes, die neue Rolle als
NATO-Mitglied und die strategische Bedeutung des Nordens. Es geht um die Lage in
der Ostsee, russische Provokationen, klare Regeln für den Einsatz von Drohnen
und darum, wie eng Deutschland und Schweden inzwischen sicherheitspolitisch
verzahnt sind.
Das Berlin Playbook als Podcast gibt es morgens um 5 Uhr. Gordon Repinski und
das POLITICO-Team bringen euch jeden Morgen auf den neuesten Stand in Sachen
Politik — kompakt, europäisch, hintergründig.
Und für alle Hauptstadt-Profis:
Unser Berlin Playbook-Newsletter liefert jeden Morgen die wichtigsten Themen und
Einordnungen. Hier gibt es alle Informationen und das kostenlose Playbook-Abo.
Mehr von Berlin Playbook-Host und Executive Editor von POLITICO in Deutschland,
Gordon Repinski, gibt es auch hier:
Instagram: @gordon.repinski | X: @GordonRepinski.
Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk warned that the end of Russia’s war in Ukraine
might lead to efforts to rekindle economic ties with Russia — including the
restarting of the controversial Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline.
As Europe faces the possibility of peace negotiations between Russia and
Ukraine, Tusk described calls by European politicians to rebuild ties to Moscow
at the eventual end of the war as “an alarm bell.”
“[I know] it means that someone in Europe wants to restore Nord Stream 2, to
have good business with oil and gas from Russia, and so on,” he said. “For me,
it’s always like an alarm bell,” Tusk said in an interview with the Sunday
Times.
A major pipeline transporting gas from Russia to Germany via the Baltic Sea,
Nord Stream 2 is described by critics as a strategic mistake and a symbol of
Europe’s appeasement to Moscow.
The pipeline was blown up in 2022 after the start of Russian President Vladimir
Putin’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine. A Ukrainian professional diver was later
arrested over his suspected involvement in the sabotage.
“The problem with North Stream 2 is not that it was blown up. The problem is
that it was built,” Tusk wrote on X social media earlier this month.
In the Sunday Times interview, Tusk said that a Polish court ruling blocking a
German extradition request for one of the suspects in the Nord Stream sabotage
means that Ukraine has a right to attack Russia-linked targets anywhere in
Europe.
The Polish leader also berated Europe’s complacency and its constant underrating
of Putin’s expansionist threats. “We are talking about the end of the era of
illusions in Europe — too late, I’m afraid. Too late to be well prepared for all
the threats, but not too late to survive,” Tusk said.
Also in the interview, Tusk described Britain’s exit from the EU as “one of the
biggest mistakes in our [shared European] history”— 10 years after U.K. Prime
Minister David Cameron’s ill-fated attempt to use the Brexit referendum as
leverage to extract concessions from the EU.
“And today I think it’s much more visible,” said Tusk, who was well-steeped in
the first phase of the Brexit negotiations as president of the European Council
at the time.
“Especially after Brexit, Poles realized that the objective situation in the
U.K. is not much better than in Poland. I also know that Brits are starting to
leave the U.K. and begin a life here in Poland,” he said.
A Helsinki court ruled Friday that it didn’t have jurisdiction over damage to
undersea power and data cables in the Gulf of Finland allegedly caused by the
captain and two officers of the Russia-linked oil tanker Eagle S.
“The District Court has today issued a judgment dismissing the charge in the
case … along with the claims for damages arising from the charge, as it was not
possible to apply Finnish criminal law to the case,” the court said in a
statement.
Finland had filed criminal charges in August against Captain Davit Vadatchkoria
and officers Robert Egizaryan and Santosh Kumar Chaurasia of the suspected
shadow fleet ship Eagle S sailing under the flag of the Cook Islands, accusing
them of damaging five telecom cables in the Gulf of Finland last December with
the vessel’s anchor.
Prosecutors sought prison terms of more than two years, warning the incident
could have sparked blackouts and power price spikes.
The incident fueled calls to crack down on Russia’s “shadow fleet” and prompted
NATO to step up seabed patrols following a string of cable disruptions in the
region.
The trial was also seen as a test case for holding actors accountable for
attacks on critical seabed infrastructure. But it collapsed over maritime law
provisions and doubts about intent.
The court sided with the defense, ruling the damage occurred outside Finnish
jurisdiction and ordering the state to reimburse the legal fees of the
defendants.
Judges acknowledged the cable breaks caused economic damage to Finnish firms,
but said the risk of widespread blackouts was unlikely as it required “other
serious disturbances” alongside extreme weather.
The three defendants, who denied any wrongdoing, were barred from leaving
Finland for nine months but departed in September after their travel ban was
lifted.
PARIS — The French military on Wednesday arrested two crew members on a tanker
suspected of belonging to Russia’s shadow fleet and of having been involved in
drone disturbances in Denmark last week, according to the French prosecutor’s
office.
French military personal boarded the Boracay, a Benin-flagged tanker that is
suspected of being used by Russia to bypass EU sanctions, according to pictures
taken by the AFP news agency.
The tanker is also suspected of having served as a launchpad for the drones seen
in Denmark last week ahead of an EU leaders’ summit in Copenhagen. The Boracay
was positioned more than 50 kilometers outside the Port of Saint-Nazaire on
Wednesday after travelling from the Russian Port of Primorsk in the Baltic Sea,
according to shipping data checked by POLITICO.
The two crew members, the captain and his deputy, were arrested on charges of
refusing to obey a summons and failing to justify the ship’s nationality,
according to the prosecutor’s office.
Discussions between EU leaders in Copenhagen Oct. 1 were dominated by Russia
drone incursions against EU countries and a proposal by the European Commission
to create a “drone wall” on its eastern frontier in response to the sightings.
Speaking after the arrests, Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen said she
couldn’t comment on “specific investigations” but noted that countries were
“facing lots of problems with the shadow fleet in the Baltic Sea.”
On Wednesday morning, French President Emmanuel Macron said “a very important
operation” was ongoing in relation to the Boracay. “There were very important
offenses committed by the crew which justify the legal proceedings,” he said on
arrival at the summit.
Macron refrained, however, from linking the ship to the drone sightings.
According to the Guardian, the Kremlin said on Wednesday it had no information
about a ship suspected of belonging to the Russian shadow fleet off the coast of
France.
Gabriel Gavin contributed reporting.
NATO will send more warplanes and air defense systems to the eastern flank in
response to Russian drone incursions into Polish airspace, the alliance’s top
officials announced Friday.
“Today, NATO is launching Eastern Sentry to bolster our posture along eastern
flank,” Secretary-General Mark Rutte told reporters.
On Wednesday, Polish and Dutch fighter jets scrambled to shoot down Russian
drones in Poland’s airspace, in one of most serious violations of a NATO
country’s sovereignty.
Eastern Sentry, which starts Friday, will be modeled after Baltic Sentry, where
frigates, aircraft and drones monitor the Baltic Sea. NATO allies will also
experiment with new technologies such as counter-drones, sensors and weapons in
Eastern Sentry, said Supreme Allied Commander Europe Gen. Alexus Grynkewich.
The mission — described as an “entire new defense design” — will also integrate
current “individual air policing actions and individual ground based air
defenses.” Denmark, France, the U.K. and Germany have already offered
contributions including fighter jets, ships and ground-based air defense
systems.
Grynkewich hailed Wednesday’s operation in Polish airspace as a success, but
said NATO is working to get “lower cost weapons that we can use to defend
ourselves to make this a sustainable operation over time.”
Rutte — echoing U.S. President Donald Trump but going against Poland and
Germany’s assessment — refused to explicitly say that the Russian incursion was
intentional.
“We are still assessing,” he said. “Whether or not Russia’s actions were
deliberate, they violated NATO air space. The question is relevant but not that
relevant — in both cases, it’s reckless, unacceptable.”
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen wants the EU to help
front-line countries monitor and defend their borders against potential Russian
aggression — backing a long-standing request from Poland and Baltic nations.
“There is no doubt: Europe’s eastern flank keeps all of Europe safe. From the
Baltic Sea to the Black Sea. This is why we must invest in supporting it through
an Eastern Flank Watch,” she told European lawmakers in her State of the Union
address Wednesday morning.
“This means giving Europe independent strategic capabilities. We must invest in
real-time space surveillance so that no movement of forces goes unseen. We must
heed the call of our Baltic friends and build a drone wall,” the German
politician added.
Von der Leyen’s comments came only a few hours after Poland scrambled fighter
jets to shoot down Russian drones that entered its airspace. Back in June,
Romania also sent warplanes to monitor Russian drones approaching its border.
Wednesday’s incident over Poland has been perceived by Western allies as a way
for Russian President Vladimir Putin to test NATO’s defenses.
Front-line countries — especially Poland, Estonia and Lithuania — have long
called for the EU to contribute financially to the defense of their borders.
They argue their efforts will protect the bloc as a whole against any attack
from Russia, as military and intelligence top brass have warned in the past that
Putin could target Baltic nations or Poland to test NATO’s mettle.
They have successfully pushed for money from the EU’s loans-for-weapons SAFE
scheme to be easily available for items including drones and anti-drone systems.
Warsaw launched a project last year dubbed East Shield that aims to strengthen
the Polish border with Russia and Belarus, while Baltic nations are starting to
teach children to build and fly drones. Countries such as Lithuania are also
behind the idea of a “drone wall,” which they see as a permanent presence of
unmanned aerial vehicles on their borders to monitor threats.
A few days before giving her State of the Union address, von der Leyen went on a
front-line state tour that took her to countries including Finland, Estonia,
Lithuania, Latvia and Poland.
“Last week, I saw this for myself when I visited front-line member states. They
know best the threat Russia poses,” she told European lawmakers on Wednesday.
Von der Leyen also announced the EU will enter into a so-called Drone Alliance
with Ukraine and front-load €6 billion from the G7-led Extraordinary Revenue
Acceleration (ERA).
Russia’s war in Ukraine has highlighted the importance of drones in warfare —
they can be used for surveillance purposes and as lethal weapons to reach remote
or dangerous areas. Ukraine is widely perceived as being innovative with the
technology, namely through the use of AI and automation.
Von der Leyen gave few details about the defense road map she has to present to
EU leaders in October, but did say she wants to launch a so-called European
Semester of Defence to monitor capitals’ progress in military buildup.